What do you believe in?

A General Discussion forum for cars and other topics, and a great place to introduce yourself if you are new to NICO!
crzycav86
Posts: 3836
Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 1:28 pm
Car: 93 Nissan 240SX KAT

Post

NY94J30 wrote:A quick syllogism:

Without reason one cannot make an argument.

Faith is an abrogation of reason.

Hence, one cannot base an argument on faith.


That may be partially true, but if one were to argue the existence of God, he wouldn't use faith to do that. He would use reason.

As far as arguing which religion is correct, I agree that one's person's beliefs are just as valid as the next guy's.... but something that is difficult for me to understand is why so many people can't see that God exists..... such a great dilemma...


jdmfreak
Posts: 9350
Joined: Thu Jul 03, 2003 5:06 am
Contact:

Post

So true. Sure there are things that come up in life that bring upon doubts about God, but in the end those doubts go away. Even scientists are now leaning towards the fact that there may azctually be an existing God because they now realize that something can not come from nothing.

User avatar
RobDET
Posts: 1553
Joined: Wed May 07, 2003 5:51 pm
Car: Cars

Post

not trying to argue or anything but at some point wether there is a god or not something came from nothing... even god had to have a reason...

Physics was very different in the instant the univers came into being... If you are a fan of the big bang theory it is most likely that you have it all wrong... It was not a huge chunk of stuff but an infinately small, infinately massive chunk of stuff... Out side that chunk there were no laws or rules or anything... There was in fact nothing... When the pull of that vacuum of nothing became great enough the big bang happened... You can't really think it terms of size or of energy released because like i said the laws of physics don't apply. Scope out some relitivity theory and see what happens when things get really really small (near the atomic level)

There is also a good theory that the universe doesn't come from some big bang but that the tension between "stuff" (stars molecules nissans exc) causes matter to form. Somewhere deep down at an atomic level.

Speakin of math... Isn't it odd the numbers that come up all the time... go read about PI and the mandelbrot set. Or look up PI in strange places... It's really interesting.

Anyway back on topic sence noone will read this... I don't really see a way to quantitatively talk about god... or even reasonably arguing his existance...

jdmfreak
Posts: 9350
Joined: Thu Jul 03, 2003 5:06 am
Contact:

Post

Well we really cant be sure as you most likely already know. Until it is proven with physical evidence, there will be an everlasting battle of right vs. wrong when it comes to this subject. I cant say that one person is wrong with their beliefs because there is no actual proof. I, myself do not believe in the big bang, but I will not say it is wrong.

User avatar
RobDET
Posts: 1553
Joined: Wed May 07, 2003 5:51 pm
Car: Cars

Post

cool... I'm gonna duck out of this discussion... I probibly shouldn't have stuck my nose in at all... I definately believe in God (god) but my definition is slightly different...

.02

Stoneage_Turbo
Posts: 2178
Joined: Tue Jul 23, 2002 3:33 am
Car: 1994 Caddy Deville 4.9
Just about anything

Post

1. Islam (100%) 2. Orthodox Judaism (100%) 3. Bahá'í Faith (96%) 4. Reform Judaism (90%) 5. Sikhism (84%) 6. Jainism (81%) 7. Orthodox Quaker (80%) 8. Liberal Quakers (75%) 9. Mainline to Conservative Christian/Protestant (68%) 10. Seventh Day Adventist (66%) 11. Unitarian Universalism (65%) 12. Mainline to Liberal Christian Protestants (64%) 13. Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (Mormons) (63%) 14. Neo-Pagan (59%) 15. Eastern Orthodox (58%) 16. Roman Catholic (58%) 17. Jehovah's Witness (57%) 18. Hinduism (56%) 19. Mahayana Buddhism (56%) 20. New Age (48%) 21. Theravada Buddhism (46%) 22. Scientology (40%) 23. Secular Humanism (38%) 24. Nontheist (36%) 25. Taoism (33%) 26. New Thought (31%) 27. Christian Science (Church of Christ, Scientist) (27%)

ok the revrend is really scratching his head now , i never thought i was islamic , i hardly went to church and when i did it was always a diffrent church from the last time , picking up what i liked about each religion and form that as my own belif

someone needs to clear this up as i think , there is one god ,a jesus , heaven ,hell among other things..... does that synch up with islam ? i dont know much about it so im thinking i awnsered the test wrong or something , i know almost nothing about islam so....

User avatar
NY94J30
Posts: 1447
Joined: Mon Jul 22, 2002 4:40 pm
Car: 2000 Q45 AE
Location: New York

Post

Islam has one god (Allah) the same god as the Christian and Jewish gods,and Jesus (Isa), and heaven (Janna) and hell. However, in Islam, Jesus is not the son of God - God is singular - but one of the prophets , like Moses (Musa) and Abraham (Ibrahim) and David (Daoud) to name a few.

crzycav86
Posts: 3836
Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 1:28 pm
Car: 93 Nissan 240SX KAT

Post

RobDET wrote:not trying to argue or anything but at some point wether there is a god or not something came from nothing... even god had to have a reason...


You mean even God had to have a reason to come into being? If thats the case, I disagree. God is something unfathomable, when theological scholars over the centuries have tried to reason his existence, all they got was headaches. The only thing I can conclude from all this is that we have been built without the capabilities to understand where God came from.

....and if thats not what you meant, oh well...

TurboKA37
Posts: 2602
Joined: Sat Jun 14, 2003 10:55 am
Contact:

Post

when did god begin?

User avatar
szh
Posts: 15932
Joined: Tue Jul 23, 2002 12:54 pm
Car: 2018 Tesla Model 3.

Unfortunately, no longer a Nissan or Infiniti, but continuing here at NICO!
Location: San Jose, CA

Post

NY94J30 wrote:Islam has one god (Allah) the same god as the Christian and Jewish gods,and Jesus (Isa), and heaven (Janna) and hell. However, in Islam, Jesus is not the son of God - God is singular - but one of the prophets , like Moses (Musa) and Abraham (Ibrahim) and David (Daoud) to name a few.


And (this is surprising to a lot of people in the US - I suppose everywhere), Islam also accepts Judaism and Christianity as other words of God. All people of the Books. This tends to get lost with all the politization (if there is such a word) that goes on everywhere - on all sides in the Middle East, for example.

It is too easy to fear the unknown and stereotype the different ... sigh!

Z

User avatar
szh
Posts: 15932
Joined: Tue Jul 23, 2002 12:54 pm
Car: 2018 Tesla Model 3.

Unfortunately, no longer a Nissan or Infiniti, but continuing here at NICO!
Location: San Jose, CA

Post

Stoneage_Turbo wrote:1. Islam (100%) 2. Orthodox Judaism (100%) 3. Bahá'í Faith (96%) 4. Reform Judaism (90%)

ok the revrend is really scratching his head now , i never thought i was islamic , i hardly went to church and when i did it was always a diffrent church from the last time , picking up what i liked about each religion and form that as my own belif

someone needs to clear this up as i think , there is one god ,a jesus , heaven ,hell among other things..... does that synch up with islam ? i dont know much about it so im thinking i awnsered the test wrong or something , i know almost nothing about islam so....


FWIW, I am Muslim - albeit hardly what I would call a practising one - and here my top results:

1. Reform Judaism (100%)2. Liberal Quakers (87%)3. Sikhism (85%)4. Unitarian Universalism (79%)5. Islam (79%)6. Orthodox Judaism (79%)7. Bahá'í Faith (74%)

Probably has to do with the fact that there are a plenty of similarities in Judaism and Islam, I would guess.

Z

User avatar
szh
Posts: 15932
Joined: Tue Jul 23, 2002 12:54 pm
Car: 2018 Tesla Model 3.

Unfortunately, no longer a Nissan or Infiniti, but continuing here at NICO!
Location: San Jose, CA

Post

TurboKA37 wrote:when did god begin?


I have always felt that the concept of God was a human created thing. We needed to find a mystical, beyond-disbelief, accept-on-faith-without-proof, supreme entity creator, to allow us to explain the existence of whatever we do not [yet] understand. This will always be true as human knowledge continues to stay one step behind human experience.

Z

TurboKA37
Posts: 2602
Joined: Sat Jun 14, 2003 10:55 am
Contact:

Post

hmm... now i kinda see how someone could believe in a god but if god created everything who created god? and where did he exist before the universe was created? could not have existed in our minds because there were no humans.

crzycav86
Posts: 3836
Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 1:28 pm
Car: 93 Nissan 240SX KAT

Post

szhosain wrote:I have always felt that the concept of God was a human created thing. We needed to find a mystical, beyond-disbelief, accept-on-faith-without-proof, supreme entity creator, to allow us to explain the existence of whatever we do not [yet] understand. This will always be true as human knowledge continues to stay one step behind human experience.

Z


I'm glad you brought that up. My ex-gf(an athiest) brought up something similar to that, and I didn't know how to answer. I did ask her how she could possibly explain something as outrageous as miracles such as speaking in tongues and stigmata. You could probably see it on tv(a spectacular interview aired on fox a few years ago which was about a woman in a central/southern american country who experienced stigmata daily). But I don't expect you to believe any of that. There are also unexplainable christian relics such as undecayed bodies after hundreds of years, the shroud of torin, fulfilled prophecies.. etc.. all of these promote the idea that God exists. and I think there would be more theists if these relics were more widely publicized

....now I think I'm just ranting... but you get the idea.

User avatar
szh
Posts: 15932
Joined: Tue Jul 23, 2002 12:54 pm
Car: 2018 Tesla Model 3.

Unfortunately, no longer a Nissan or Infiniti, but continuing here at NICO!
Location: San Jose, CA

Post

TurboKA37 wrote:hmm... now i kinda see how someone could believe in a god but if god created everything who created god?
That is exactly where the faith and suspend-disbelief part comes in! :) The concept of God includes an existence without a need for His own creation. Quote » and where did he exist before the universe was created? could not have existed in our minds because there were no humans. [/quote] That is an extension of the point I was making. IF you accept the answer I suggested to your question, then there was no God till we humans decided that there must be one.

BTW, I am not saying I am right ... merely postulating one answer to your question (and this answer has already been debated similarly by many people before me, so I am not unique here).

Also, I happen to feel that if a Supreme Being, i.e., God, does exist, then he/she/it/whatever does not know or care about our existence, because we are too infinitesimal a part of the universe - it is arrogant for us to assume otherwise. We gave up about the Earth as the Center of the Universe a long time ago, and need to do the same about our very existence. :)

When I was very young, my Dad once told me that he heard a Muslim cleric remark that "God makes every leaf of every tree move when the wind blows". And my dad disagreed, saying instead "God made the law that when the wind blew, a leaf would move; so when the wind blows, the leaves move". I merely extend that story to its logical extreme position in my words above.

If I am stepping on toes here, then please feel free to ignore me - I am not trying to do anything more than state some of my views and beliefs that I have come to accept over time.

Z

crzycav86
Posts: 3836
Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 1:28 pm
Car: 93 Nissan 240SX KAT

Post

TurboKA37 wrote:hmm... now i kinda see how someone could believe in a god but if god created everything who created god? and where did he exist before the universe was created? could not have existed in our minds because there were no humans.


God is an absolute, he wasn't created, he's just always been there for all of time. (Time is used loosely here as there is no time in heaven) If you're looking at it from a theist's perspective, you could always say that God created us with limited minds that are incapable of understanding him... Thats our little trump card the we play when our heads start hurting :)

I also want to mention that we had a huge (25-30 page) debate over issues like this on a thread at j-body.org [its a cavalier site ;)]. One of the debaters argued that if God could be an absolute, why couldn't the universe be one? He believes that the universe has always been here, and wasn't created, just as I say that God wasn't created

bdawg46
Posts: 125
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2003 8:15 pm

Post

The truth is it doesnt matter hwta you believe. Let me explain real quickly and simply. If you believe there is a pot of gold at the end of a rainbow, does that make it truth??? No, it doesnt. Jesus Christ is God and He is the only way to Heaven. If you dont believe this and never accept Jesus as your personal Saviour then you are doomed to Hell. If you believe this, then when you die you go to Heaven. i have more but i got to go, will finish later.

User avatar
szh
Posts: 15932
Joined: Tue Jul 23, 2002 12:54 pm
Car: 2018 Tesla Model 3.

Unfortunately, no longer a Nissan or Infiniti, but continuing here at NICO!
Location: San Jose, CA

Post

crzycav86 wrote:God is an absolute, he wasn't created, he's just always been there for all of time. (Time is used loosely here as there is no time in heaven) If you're looking at it from a theist's perspective, you could always say that God created us with limited minds that are incapable of understanding him... Thats our little trump card the we play when our heads start hurting :)
That is certainly a completely reasonable alternative to what I suggested.Quote »I also want to mention that we had a huge (25-30 page) debate over issues like this on a thread at j-body.org [its a cavalier site ;)]. One of the debaters argued that if God could be an absolute, why couldn't the universe be one? He believes that the universe has always been here, and wasn't created, just as I say that God wasn't created [/quote]FWIW, I happen to believe in the existence of God. But, I still do feel that the concept of such an existence is a human artifact. I.e., humans created the concept of a God because we needed one. And it provides us with a solace in scary times, and far less of an internal fear when we imagine a Universe without such an existence.

Z

TurboKA37
Posts: 2602
Joined: Sat Jun 14, 2003 10:55 am
Contact:

Post

i had a huge response writen out but i found it to be too wordy and too hard for others to understand. so ill just ask another question. do u believe in afterlife?

User avatar
NY94J30
Posts: 1447
Joined: Mon Jul 22, 2002 4:40 pm
Car: 2000 Q45 AE
Location: New York

Post

My beleif in the existance of a god(s) comes as a result of the fact that I cannot imagine sentience as a mechanical concept (i.e. purely evolutional) - I suppose this is akin to the the Deist clockmaker theory.

As for the initial existance of such a being(s), I do not believe that it can be couched in the terms that confine our own physical (temporal) reality. Time is a human construct and may well be very distorted even within our own reality, as demonstrated by Einstein and other quantum physicists.

User avatar
szh
Posts: 15932
Joined: Tue Jul 23, 2002 12:54 pm
Car: 2018 Tesla Model 3.

Unfortunately, no longer a Nissan or Infiniti, but continuing here at NICO!
Location: San Jose, CA

Post

TurboKA37 wrote:i had a huge response writen out but i found it to be too wordy and too hard for others to understand.
That didn't stop me from trying to confuse people! Go for it! :)Quote » so ill just ask another question. do u believe in afterlife? [/quote] Tough question. I simply do not know. I guess I would be more comfortable with there being an afterlife - I would hate for my brief existence here on Earth to have been so meaningless as to not deserve a continued existence somewhere else. No matter where. Or as how (if you accept the Buddhist reincarnation ideas).

Z

User avatar
szh
Posts: 15932
Joined: Tue Jul 23, 2002 12:54 pm
Car: 2018 Tesla Model 3.

Unfortunately, no longer a Nissan or Infiniti, but continuing here at NICO!
Location: San Jose, CA

Post

RobDET wrote:Speakin of math... Isn't it odd the numbers that come up all the time... go read about PI and the mandelbrot set. Or look up PI in strange places... It's really interesting.


Also the Fibonacci Sequence. If you want to read an interesting best-seller thriller that is a lot of fun reading, check out "The Da Vinci Code" by David Brown (I think).

Z

User avatar
NY94J30
Posts: 1447
Joined: Mon Jul 22, 2002 4:40 pm
Car: 2000 Q45 AE
Location: New York

Post

Z,

I also agree with much of what you said, however, rather than god as a construct to provide solace I beleive the afterlife and satan, original sin and those items of dogma one is to take on faith are those that are created to give meaning to human existance.

On another note, and perhaps more controversial, I cannot imagine a god that has created humans to worship it, or that would care if they did, much less premise reward upon it - to me that seems quite vein (a mortal or deadly sin I beleive).

TurboKA37
Posts: 2602
Joined: Sat Jun 14, 2003 10:55 am
Contact:

Post

bdawg46 wrote:The truth is it doesnt matter hwta you believe. Let me explain real quickly and simply. If you believe there is a pot of gold at the end of a rainbow, does that make it truth??? No, it doesnt. Jesus Christ is God and He is the only way to Heaven. If you dont believe this and never accept Jesus as your personal Saviour then you are doomed to Hell. If you believe this, then when you die you go to Heaven. i have more but i got to go, will finish later.


i dont agree with this. so ur saying if i dont believe in god i dont get to go to heaven and ill go to hell even if i dont believe in hell? also if ur belief is that god is created by his believers and u still believe in a afterlife. then how come if i believe in a god that allows me to become immortal, it wont happen?

User avatar
NY94J30
Posts: 1447
Joined: Mon Jul 22, 2002 4:40 pm
Car: 2000 Q45 AE
Location: New York

Post

szhosain wrote:Also the Fibonacci Sequence. If you want to read an interesting best-seller thriller that is a lot of fun reading, check out "The Da Vinci Code" by David Brown (I think).

Z


I beleive also that natural log constant (ln or Euler's number) and Pi have the same decimal distribution when carried out to an inordinate number (one million plus) of places.

bdawg46
Posts: 125
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2003 8:15 pm

Post

OK, back to right wherei left off. Now for the existence of God. This is easy to prove (atleast for me). Just look out side. Or go to the mountians. Lokk around and really think about. For me it is harder to believe that God had nothing to do with Creation than Him creaated Creation. I mean every leaf is different, and just taking a leaf as an example: out technology doubles, our knowledge about things double every 10 years (sorry i dont have the source of this fact, got it from one of those stat books or wuteva u call them), now man has been creating extraordianry stuff almost daily, but if you got the smartest men of the world and the years to come, i bet they could not creat something paper thin, something that flaps in the wind, something that changes colors as the seasons go by, something that falls off and grows back yealry, and this is just a leaf!!!!!!!! i mean take a good study of the human eye or the anatomy of humans, its so complex, it could not have evolved as soemthing had to come of being at the exact same time for us as humans to proper functionally, and to believe in evolution is just luidicris, i mean they have one theory, to back another theory, to back another theory.

Also many say that the Bible is unreliable and changes and is written by men. Well the Bible has been around thousands of years and has not changed if it has, it was nothing significant to prove it wrong or to dissprove its doctrine. And yes men wrote it, BUT it was God that used them. God wrote through them.

Also, about getting to heavens by "good deeds" is not correct. "we are saved through God's grace and mercy, not by works, so that no mna can boast" - almost straight from the Bible (sorry cannot remember the exact verse, PM and i will look it up for u) Jesus Christ died on the cross so that we could have eternal life with Him, He conquered sin, which no human can do. and we all sin, that is a clear fact. And all you have to do to go to heaven is "confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe it in your heart and you will be saved" - almost straight from the Bible as well (PM me). now notice it does not say might be saved, should be, maybe be saved, you WILL be saved. But u must mean it. And that is the start, u do not simply say it and mean it, then turn your back on God. If you truly meant it, everything else will follow. Of course it is not easy, it takes great faith to believe in Jesus. Most ppl dont do it cuz they will get laoughed at or you "cant have fun" as a true Christain. And once you make the decision ot follof Christ it does not become easier, it will prolly become harder, another reason many choose not to follow. But it will be worth, the ultimate prize of of eternal life, the ulitmate prize to have God say "you have doen well my child" i myslef cannot wait for the day i go to heaven. To see God, to ask him all the question that our minds now cant fathom about him. Like i said it takes great faith. and once you truly belive and maybe find a true Christain as your local pastor or sumthin, everything else will follow. I dont know how to end this really long post, but my hope is it reaches someone. take care.

crzycav86
Posts: 3836
Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 1:28 pm
Car: 93 Nissan 240SX KAT

Post

NY94J30 wrote:Z,

On another note, and perhaps more controversial, I cannot imagine a god that has created humans to worship it, or that would care if they did, much less premise reward upon it - to me that seems quite vein (a mortal or deadly sin I beleive).


I don't think the Catholic church teaches that God created us to worship him. I think God was too full of love that was contained inside himself and heaven, so he created humans(and the universe) in order to have more things to shower his love upon, in return we are obligated to love him back. Its not just a one way thing. God loves us too. Its a mutual thing. Similar to a person's marriage with his wife.

These thoughts aren't necessarily what the church teaches, just what i believe

bdawg46
Posts: 125
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2003 8:15 pm

Post

TurboKA37 - i am not clearly reading ur question. alos i do not have all the answer u make be seeking but i will do my best.

Yes, even you dont believe in Hell, it still exist. whether YOU believe in it or not. sorry if that hutrs, but thats the best way i can put it

the seond part of tour question is the part i do not understand. I beleive that God never started and has always been, this is something we as humans cannot understand and where faith takes more place than knowledeg.

User avatar
szh
Posts: 15932
Joined: Tue Jul 23, 2002 12:54 pm
Car: 2018 Tesla Model 3.

Unfortunately, no longer a Nissan or Infiniti, but continuing here at NICO!
Location: San Jose, CA

Post

NY94J30 wrote:Z,

I also agree with much of what you said, however, rather than god as a construct to provide solace I beleive the afterlife and satan, original sin and those items of dogma one is to take on faith are those that are created to give meaning to human existance.
No argument from me really. Like that old saying goes: "Without Evil, there is no Good". I.e., you have to measure against something.

Something similar could be said about the existence of Satan too: there can be no God without Satan. I think I remember reading that that was one of the observations that Satan made to God about the reason for his existence.

We humans need something to explain good events (they come from God) and bad events (they come from Satan or a disbelief in God). That is where the solace (and perhaps the natural human desire to thank/blame/fault something or somebody else) comes in.Quote »On another note, and perhaps more controversial, I cannot imagine a god that has created humans to worship it, or that would care if they did, much less premise reward upon it - to me that seems quite vein (a mortal or deadly sin I beleive). [/quote]That is a very similar comment to what I said too! But, I go further ... I don't think God knows we even exist, let alone wants us to worhip Him - heck, He might be surprised if he "heard" that we attributed this desire to Him! :)

Z

bdawg46
Posts: 125
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2003 8:15 pm

Post

Also, before its asked (or if alrdy was) "why did God create man?" or anything is that case. this one is actaully pretty simple. we do not know and will not know until i can ask him myslef in heaven. Y he created everything is speculation as He does not tell us y. Also, i donot have all the answers, only the word of God (which i dont have memorized so bear with me plz)


Return to “General Chat”