Post by
nabril »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/nabril-u245099.html
Mon Apr 21, 2025 8:45 am
Dear NIcoClub friends
I write to vent, that's right, to vent.
After putzing around with the second transmission oil change for my wife's 16 Rogue since October or so, I was finally ready to do it.
I asked member @VStar650cl 650 questions, bought 2 different types of Eneos oil that I could find, bought the pan gasket, inside screen and the outside filter both from Nissan and Amazon; I would return what I didn't use obviously. I also went to Harbor Freight to get a longer breaker bar.
For some time, my wife complained of a loud noise when she drove. We took it to a retired mechanic friend, and upon a quick audio inspection, he suggested that it could be the wheel hubs. But the car needs to be lifted and properly diagnosed, and so we did. This other mechanic drove it, lifted it up, and accelerated with it lifted. He ruled out the wheel hubs, and pointed to a faulty transmission. Our jaws dropped because of that that implies. Minutes later I thought about all the planning I had done for the oil change...
I lifted the car up yesterday on 2 jacks, spun the front wheels freely, and I didn't hear any noise nor did the wheels have any play in any direction.
What's next? Well, she's looking at other cars because getting a rebuilt transmission installed will cost about as much as the car is worth, we were told; I sold my 15 Rogue to CarMax in January, and got $7k for it. Her 16 perhaps can fetch $8k.
EDIT - Carmax quoted $10.6k for it
The 2nd mechanic was very forthright and honest and left the decision to us, obviously.
Are we jumping the gun here? The car has been well kept, only has 72k miles, and was going to be inherited by my daughter. Mistakenly, I did many oil changes, but only ONE transmission oil change back at 42k miles. So, one could say that the transmission issue could be my lack of love and care for it.
Do we price out a new transmission? From Nissan?
Or do I have it rebuilt?
Aghhhhhhhhhhhhh
thank you