In preparing to do this job, I read what I could find here and on Q45.org. I came across this...
"NOTE: There are 4 guides, a slack-side guide, 2 tension guides and an oil pump chain guide. The slack-side guide has ALWAYS been metal backed and is NOT part of the problem. The problem lies with the tension guide and oil pump guide. These are all plastic and must be replaced."
So I got mine apart and found the noise I was hearing was the oil pump chain. For some reason, the upper guide was not adjusted properly to apply tension on the chain. The bolts were tight, and there was no evidence that the guide had moved. How it came to be in this condition, I have no idea. Anyway, I have two comments on the above quote. First, there are 6 guides, not 4. Second, on my car the two slack side guides on the cam chains are both plastic, and both stamped with a build date of 2/91. Obviously the slack side guide has not always been metal.So now that I've got mine apart and know what I'm looking at, I'm a little more confused. Both the guides on my oil pump chain were metal backed, as were both the tension side guides on the cam chains. I originally thought they had been replaced.However, this article (
http://www.q45.org/guidereplacement.html) seems to show exactly the same setup as mine. Metal backed guides on the tension side, plastic on the slack side. Is that the original setup? Have the tension side guides always been metal? Is there a specific point to replacing the original (?) metal backed guides with new metal backed guides, or are we just doing this because it all comes in the kit? If plastic guides are the problem, and only the slack side guide is plastic, why not just replace those two and call it a day? Am I missing something here? Thanks
BTW - 206k on those original slack side (plastic) guides.