redtop91 wrote:I actually don't have Mario Kart. My R4DS came in the other day and I downloaded Zelda: Phantom Hourglass. Pretty fun so far. I can't say I'm sold on not being able to use the D pad or any buttons for controls though... Everything is touch screen :-(
Phantom hourglass was a mixed bag for me. It was sort of a Zelda game, but it really wasn't. The Music and art were Zelda. But the gameplay could have worn any name.The touch screen controls were definitely unnecessary and got in the way at times, but they were nowhere near as bad as I feared they'd be. Still, at least an option for gimmick-free gameplay would have been nice. I mean...yeah it was a good idea in early development when the DS was new and touch screen games were fresh. But Phantom Hourglass was a few years late for that party. They should have ditched the touch screen altogether.
But the thing that really killed it as a Zelda game for me was the lack of Zelda content. No heart containers/pieces of heart to hunt down. No optional collection side quests except the very minimal treasure hunting.Zelda games should have more than combat and dungeons. And even the dungeons got the short straw. You start out with every dungeon map, there's no compass, and the major dungeon is revisited umpteen times until you could do it in your sleep and indeed would probably prefer to be asleep through it.
The music and art design were excellent, though. But I can get those with Windwaker, which is a real Zelda game with real Zelda content. It just doesn't fit in my pocket. Pretty disappointing that the portable Zelda built on the most powerful system had the least content. The old green-and-white Gameboy Link's Awakening was a vastly superior game. Maybe Nintendo should have put time into making the game rather than screwing around with touch screen controls that no one but themselves want to have to use.
And on the subject of DS dungeon-crawlers:Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles: Ring of Fates is a lot of fun. It lacks a few of the iconic traits of it's Gamecube progenitor, but it makes up for them by adding new stuff and getting rid of the blasted Miasma.