Chrispy300 wrote:
Don't they have some sort of bypass valve for when the throttles is shut? You'd think that a PD blower into a closed throttle would only be bad news?
Centrifugal blowers are driven off the crankshaft and hold faily non-linear boost curves because the VE of the blower rarely matches the VE of the engine. You tend to get boost creep with these setups, and sometimes the bypass valve is used to regulate this, but not often. A centrifugal blower compresses the air BEFORE the throttle body much like a tubocharger, and as a result HAS a bypass/BOV to release the pressure when the throttle is closed, just as you've speculated.
A Positive Displacement blow is installed downstream of the throttle body, so there is no pressure on the atmospheric side of the throttle plate when it is closed. A roots type PD blower is not a compressor as much as it is a pump. The whole idea is that you set the blower to pump x times as much air as the engine intakes at a given RPM. If the engine flows 4.5L of air per cycle, then the blower might be driven to pump 6.75L of air per cycle resulting in 7.5psi ob boost pressure. The beauty of this is that the relationship remains failrly constant along a very broad RPM range resulting in near instantaneous off idle boost response and a broad flat torque curve. The downside is heat, and lots of it. That's why water to air IC's are placed between the blower and the manifold to cool the charge, and they're pretty much necessary at any boost pressure above 4 or 5 psi. A screw type PD supercharger does the same thing, but it also has an internal compression ration resulting in more boost as less RPM. Since the whipple can make the same pressure at lower RPM, it can either A: be underdriven resulting in less heat and more power than a similar size roots blower. Or B: Be undersized and overdriven resulting in the same heat as the roots blower, but a smaller package freeing up more space under the hood. Screw type blowers (Kenne Bell, Whipple) are very efficient compares to roots blowers. Still not as good as a turbo or centrifugal, but the broad torque is usually desireable as a tradeoff to it's downfalls.
PD blowers DO have bypass valves as well, but they recirculate between both sides of the blower when the throttle is closed so that air can bypass the blower to keep things cool. PD Sc's actually make more heat at idle and part throttle than when working to make boost pressure. Because of this their water to air cooling setups need to have a high volume to prevent heat soak.
Ok, I'm gunna shut up now...