madbouncy wrote:Yeah that's pretty much it, it's usually easier for bigger turbos to flow air so they won't make as much heat. But you also have to look at the compressor efficiency and stuff. If you put a large turbo into a really low efficiency and the small turbo at it's peak, you can get the little one to generate less heat. But I'm really new to turbos, so you're better off asking like Ivan or somebody else who has worked on lots of different cars with lots of different turbos. I'm sure he's seen enough dynos to know what really happens and not just what physics and stuff says.
It's not necessarily easier for a larger turbo to flow air. You have to look at the actual amount of airflow at the boost it will be running. The compressor efficiency is a direct representation of the aerodynamics of a compressor assembly. A larger turbo will tend towards moving more air at higher efficiencies, but it is not always better. If you try to run a low amount of boost with too large a turbo and it will be running in a lower efficiency area of the map. Run the same boost on a better matched turbo (perhaps smaller) and you'll be running at a flow rate and boost level that is more aerodynamic. This translates to lower charge temperatures, and will be easier for the turbine to turn. Essentiually, this equates to less backpressure. The turbo that is sized too big will need to try and run a higher pressure differential across the turbine to drive the compressor. Too large can be as bad as running too small from an efficiency standpoint. Only, you'll have a high boost threshold and slow turbo response to go with it.
My point? For best results, decide on the final result you want before picking a turbo. Choose the turbo that best matches your goals. If you have a goal to run varying amounts of boost (i.e. higher boost at tracks with race gas), perhaps you might consider a turbo with a more flexible compressor map. While choosing an ideal turbo onb paper can be easy enough, the real world limits availability of certain turbos and being close may be a good option as well. The difference between the best match and a close match will probably not be measurable from the driver's seat. As soneone already mentioned, you are not building some high tech race car. And if you were, you have a lot to learn about turbos before even considering it.
Finally, Craving4Boost, as far as starting a new thread...if you have nothing constructive to add to this thread, then don't. Personally, I have not been able to post as much as I used to. Seeing the old posts helps me to get a better idea of what was discussed and understand where the thread is going. Not everyone will share your opinions. Simply answering the questions and moving on is easier and more constructive than making some petty complaint.