Post by
96Qowner »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/96qowner-u19561.html
Mon Sep 22, 2008 6:30 am
I'm currently the "full time" Moderator for this forum, so any complaints are my fault.
I'm an old guy and I've been posting on forums for many years, so I'm not much into the high drama that so many seem to enjoy. I detest having to break up arguments between people who claim to be adults. I figure that people who act like A-holes must enjoy being A-holes, and through the years I've come to realize that nothing I do is going to change that. I just ignore them and hope that others can learn to do the same. Yes, nothing requires anyone to post if they have nothing to say. But, again, I've never noticed that pointing out such an obvious thing changes how people behave on an online forum. Yes, people post things in a manner that they never would in r/l.
So, uh huh, we could issue warnings to folks, and delete posts, and even ban people. But I see very few offenses worth banning a member - mostly just irrelevant, self-serving posts that are not at all helpful to the original poster. Do we ride this forum with a hard hand? Why? On the one hand, we want easy natural banter. On the other hand, we don't want people to be A-holes.
Since we're all grownups (most of us) we're responsible for what we say. On a searchable forum, the things we say never disappear. They're all there to study, whereas in r/l a person can claim that he didn't really say what he said and no one can go back and replay and study it - it just passes. Not on a forum. The people who post like A-holes are always going to be known as A-holes. Suit yourselves.
I delete posts that consist of nothing but an insult. That rarely happens. What happens, as Mike says, it that people just refuse to be terribly helpful. So, as a Moderator, how do I force people to be helpful? I don't. That's the choice of each and every one of the regulars that take their time to volunteer to be helpful. They're volunteering.
Yes, part of the change we're seeing is the aging of the G50 and the Q45 in general. We're getting more of the kind of owner that doesn't respect the car as most of us respect it. What used to be a $6000 car is now a $800 car. Few new buyers of G50s give a rat's behind for bringing the car back to its magnificent glory, so it's frustrating for those of us who appreciate it for what it is.
Also, every problem, every quirk, has been thoroughly examined in past threads, and most of us remember that. Those who used to be very engaged and helpful have just gotten tired of patiently going through every step for a new owner. Our posts grow shorter and less detailed. We use shorthand. We tell people to take a look at the GD manual, for pete's sake, or, gosh, try searching maybe, huh? Not terribly helpful to a newbie. But don't forget what happens when someone comes here with a great attitude and a sincere desire to listen to Q45 experts.
Most recently, heatherin951 came to us with a troubling transmission problem. She has listened, followed up on our advice, tackled the problem in a rational step-by-step process and is narrowing it down. She got great help. It used to be that most new posters came with that attitude and were impressed and grateful for the advice. That is changing, and it's frustrating for the regulars. Yes, many of the new posters are just looking for an excuse to be all offended and to argue with us - not helpful to anyone, so we have to take on an additional burden of patience.
I've never really understood why people take the time to post if they don't have anything helpful to say, but I've also noticed that it continues, year after year, on any particular forum you choose to read - that's just the way online forums are. I would advise people who roll their eyes at yet another post about something we've covered a gazillion times to do a search, since we know the threads are there, and offer them for the newbie to read, instead of issuing useless, unhelpful opinions about him or his desire to put dubs on his ratty old valve-cover smoking, suspension rotted, piece of crap G50.
No Moderator is going to change this forum by greeting a newbie if the rest of us don't step up.
Mike, again I say you are one of the most valuable posters on this forum. Perhaps others might like to be as helpful. If not, nothing will change no matter how much anyone cajoles or complains.
The Golden Rule - nice way to put it.