Post by
MinisterofDOOM »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/ministerofdoom-u16506.html
Mon Dec 08, 2008 11:00 pm
My letter is done! (And LONG) It's condescending as hell but not angry or agressive and makes some good points. I hope to actually get some feedback from it so I'll know it's actually been read.
Here you go if you want to read it:
I'm a Davis County resident who commutes to Salt Lake City on I15 daily. This last year has been a significant one for construction, road work, and changes to the highway system where I commute. And, unfortunately, many of these changes are bad. I find my commute to be regularly unpleasant. That is why I am writing. I feel that it could be a very simple matter to drastically improve the the experience of driving on this stretch of I15 for all drivers.
The first topic I'd like to cover is the implementation of the new HOV/carpool lanes from Kaysville to Farmington (and and eventually beyond). And I specifically say "implementation" for a good reason. The lanes themselves are a topic of their own, but there is the separate issue of the exceedingly poor implementation of these new lanes. It has lead to significant congestion problem at key points.Part of the reason for this congestion is that, instead of being a new lane that splits off from normal traffic, the left lane abruptly becomes the HOV lane. This is a HUGE problem because most drivers (hereafter referred to as "stupids") are far too ignorant and narcissistic to make this transition even relatively smoothly. They're far too stupid to realize that they must vacate both left lanes unless carpooling or passing. The idea that the lane to the HOV lane's right is now the passing lane seems hopelessly beyond their grasp. So what we end up with is clueless drivers obstructing the passing lane (and therefor contributing hugely to congestion) and other clueless drivers stuck in the commuter lane that they're not supposed to be driving in. The un-crossable double-white bordering the HOV lane makes this worse, as those drivers then behave idiotically trying to decide which is worse: being in a lane they could be cited for being in, or crossing a line they could be cited for crossing.A couple of simple things can be done to help alleviate this problem. The basic idea is the same across the board: tell the stupids what to do so they don't have to try (and fail) to think for themselves. Signs should be posted sufficient distances before HOV lane transitions that inform drivers that the HOV lane will be REPLACING the left traffic lane. A simple "HOV lane ahead" with an arrow pointing left is NOT sufficient! This does not notify drivers that they must merge right to accomodate this new lane. The lane TRANSITION rather than NEW lane must be made clear.A second sign should be posted at intervals along the stretch of highway occupied by the HOV lane. It should clearly state that the new left lane (to the HOV lane's right) is no longer a normal travel lane and should be reserved for emergency vehicles and passing ONLY. There should be sufficent notice that traffic must shift right TWO LANES to leave the left two lanes open to do their jobsAs things stand now, the left 3 lanes generally remain occupied by slow drivers which prohibits passing. This means drivers must often cross multiple lanes to pass, and must then pass on the right. Both are unsafe. Something needs to be done to correct this issue. Perhaps it should even go so far as to have the left lane physically END before reopening it a few hundred yards later as the HOV lane. This would force drivers out of the lane before the transition.
This brings me to my next point:The HOV lanes are a bad idea in themselves. They do not serve their intended purpose. And the uncrossable double-white lines make them impractical. The HOV lanes would serve better as additional regular travel lanes. HOV lanes are easily defeated by stubborn drivers who refuse to drive at reasonable speeds. This leads to the HOV lane becoming it's own miniature traffic jam since the double-white cannot be crossed so no passing is possible. A clearly posted minimum speed limit of 65mph in the HOV lane would be fantastic. Perhaps even a minimum of 75 mph should be considered for that lane specifically.Instead of new speed limits, though, I propose the removal of the HOV lanes. 4 lanes of normal traffic are far more desirable and serve the whole of traffic much more positively. This would also eliminate all the above issues with the terrible implementation of these HOV lanes.A final suggestion is that Utah HOV lanes adopt a policy that some other states use. That policy is that HOV lanes are normal travel lanes (and double-whites can be crossed) during all times EXCEPT major commute hours. On weekends, at night, and other times outside "rush hours", the HOV lanes operate like normal traffic lanes. This has the benefit of offering "the best of both worlds" allowing carpoolers to benefit but keeping the HOV lanes out of the way when they are not needed.
HOV lanes aren't the only topic I want to cover here, though. The next question is of remnant construction zones. Why are there still signs denoting construction zone duration, reduced speeds while heading south from Layton? There is no construction. There are not even any cones or other orange barriers. Is speed still reduced? If so why? And if not, why are the signs still in place? Not only is the reduced speed irritating, but the mixed signals lead to the stupids causing more problems as they decided what to do. Additionally, if one was to be stopped and cited for speeding in this zone, would the construction zone penalties still be in place? Is 65mph speeding there or not? This lack of clarity is UNACCEPTABLE. If the signs are to remain present, construction should be in ACTIVE progress. If construction does not remain in progress, the signs should GO. I'm sure UDOT looses track of the purpose of highways occasionally (I've observed it many times) but they are in fact to convey automobiles from one point to another. They are NOT simply flat surfaces for hard-labor workers to endlessly employ themselves upon. The roads should be made back into fully functioning ROADS as soon as viably possible. That is their sole purpose.
Finally, I move on to the last issue I wish to cover: passing issues.I realize this is largely a UHP issue, but I still think a bit of "'stupid' handholding" could go a long way toward improvement here. UHP is lamentably bad at enforcing proper left-lane usage. Utah highways are notorious for ignorant unaware drivers impeding passing in the left lane. Everyone is familiar with the issue. It is highly problematic when a single driver can cause so much congestion. So, again, I suggest the placement of signs. They should be posted at regular intervals and state succingly that the left lane is for emergency vehicles and passing ONLY and nromal travel is NOT permitted. Signs should make clear that drivers are to vacate the left lane as soon as safely possible when not passing. This way, even if UHP continues to fall down on the job of enforcing smooth traffic operation, these drivers are made aware that they are in the wrong. This information will help them to understand why so many drivers are likely flashing high-beams and middle fingers at them and may, if we're lucky, penetrate their massive idiocy to the point that they realize their mistake and correct it, resulting in a better drive for EVERYONE on the road.
I think all agencies invovled with highway operation in Utah could improve a great deal in their demonstration to the public of the importance of SHARING the road and driving in a manner that is conducive to smooth flow of traffic for ALL cars. These are a massive issue in this state, and I genuinely hope to see them improve soon. I would be more than happy to offer more suggestions from the viewpoint of an observant, aware, safe, courteous driver should you desire them. I would be very pleased to see these ideas reach the discourteous people I share the road with so that they might realize their error and correct it. And I'm certainly open to any input you may have as well as far as how I may do my part to improve the driving experience for myself and my fellow drivers.
Thanks very much for your time. I hope you find these comments useful.