Dattebayo wrote:No. When the starter dies, it just doesn't work at all. I thought that was common knowledge!
PapaSmurf2k3 wrote:AlabamaDan wrote: It had a couple of slow starts then nothing.
This is key. When a starter goes, it pretty much just goes (like Dave said). The slow starts/slow turns indicate something else. Could your starter also be blown? Yes, but it could be coincidence.
Just because you havn't seen it, does not mean it doesn't happen.
I have replaced a handful of starters at work that were causing slow or no crank issues. What can happen, is the main power terminal on the starter can partially fail. Whether from over torquing, poor design, or just plain bad luck. It causes high resistance in the starting system, which leads to very slow cranking.
True, more often then not, a corroded power cable, or battery terminal will be the cause of a slow crank, but a bad starter should never be ruled out so quickly.
The most definitive way to test any starting system issue like this, is to voltage drop test each lead individually, starting at the battery.
PS, to the OP, make sure you try resetting the security system. It could be out of whack from the battery swap.