97ka-t wrote:
One count of detetonation could lead to blowing up any engine... I never said rotaries were reliable, they're not. In fact, as the years progressed, RX-7s became less reliable. I've seen FC's TII's with 130k on the original engines, I think the most I've seen on a FD is 100k, maybe. They are famous for their engines, not their looks. It is the combination of looks and the fact that 1.3L easily puts out 325rwhp on stock turbos. (Friend with a Power FC just dynoed last week at 326). Sure, reliability it definitely important, but I think preserving the original powerplant is imperative. This is just my opinion of course, and I'm sure plenty of other people disagree. Oh well.
My STi would see detonation all the time when I experimented with tuning and it never had any problems....as most engines can take a bit of light detonation...depends on the severity.
The problem is...detonation I was picking up from the computer wasn't audible....and that's typically not going to be a problem on most engines...but on a rotary even in-audible knock can be fatal.
My buddy has a 400 whp fc and went through 3 engines until he realized he just couldn't fudge with the tuning. He had to run the SOB rich as hell to keep the engine alive.... whereas the LS1 FD is going to put down close to 300 stock.....getting 100 extra hp is no problem at all and the engine will still be very reliable and have a lot more potential.
meh...maybe to each his own. Personally I wouldn't want to deal with a rotary...just too termperamental of an engine....not to mention worst gas mileage to liter ratio...ever.