audtatious wrote:From an unisured motorist perspective it could well have an impact assuming CA has no SSN requirement. I know my carrier requires it as they validate it and then use it for phone-in validation of who I am
Its simply a choice to validate identity. Some carriers require it for rating. Not haveing a SSN presents a challenge, but I don't think its a legal requirement.
audtatious wrote:If it is too difficult to get a job here based on legal status or validated SSN then they will leave on their own for the most part. No need to initiate some nightmare deportation sweep that will cause more problems.
But the simple fact is that this isn't a problem. In fact, even with small crowds of people looking for work forming near our hardware stores each day, there is still more work here then there. Personally, I tend to believe our minimum wage laws are partly to blame for this.
audtatious wrote:Realize I accept legal immigrants with open arms regardless of where they come from and I sympathise with those who feel they must come here and break our laws. If there was not so much of a burden on our society I would say to allow more in legally. But the fact remains that they stay on the fringe and are costing us quite a pretty penny that should be utilized to fix our own problems first. We have severe education issues and inner city issues that would be better resolved with the billions and billions of dollars that illegal immigration is causing us. Amnesty for them all is not a viable solution either.
Not arguing against the fact that they are indeed a burden. But it tends to get exaggerated propaganda style.
audtatious wrote:I read the report. My statement at the end of my above post reflected that I was not claiming that they necessarily had a higher rate (other than the offences above which they are usually not caught for) than the citizenry. Of course, the opposite view is if they were not here then the crimes they do commit would have never happened in the first place.
Perhaps, but then yoy can say that about legal immigrant groups as well. My point, however, was simply that their propensity to break the laws here are not necessarily increased by the fact that they broke laws to get here/stay here.
audtatious wrote:The crimes they commit to get here and to sustain their being here is simply a means for them to suck our economy dry. Sure, they somewhat give back with taxes and labor, but the burden to the taxpayer is far greater than what they pay back in. If they are having a problem in their own country, shouldn't they work to resolve it?
Their intent isn't to suck our economy dry. But if you're that concerned about where are money is going, I'd be more concerned with the corporations here loking for labor in other countries. There is probably a lot more money bleeding out that way.
As for resolving their issues, I doubt many of these people grew up with any formal education. Its likely much easier said than done.
audtatious wrote:Instead, they come over here and break our laws or deposit babies over here simply to have a better life off of our backs. Hospitals are closing down, clinics are full or filling up in a large number of areas, school systems are having major issues with non-english kids in english speaking classrooms, etc etc. Isn't that a pretty big burden being forced upon our citizens? While you may think it's not fair to them, what about the US citizen who no longer has a regional hospital because it is shut down or has kids in school who are falling behind because the teachers are too busy trying to teach the spanish speaking kids the english language to actually teach them or the highschool kid who can't find a job because the jobs they would normally take are all filled with illegals or when there are no apartments for rent when they get out of school and are ready to start a life? Where is the concern for our own?
Its not a concern for illegals that I'm arguing. What I don't care for is inaccurate info used to try and sway someone else's opinion of a particular group. If you feel strongly about this matter, then show some real quantifiable and relavant statistics and we can probably have a much more educated discussion. Throwing around generalizations on any subject gets us nowhere fast.
BTW, when I started Kindergarten, I didn't speak English. And I was born here.
Encryptshun wrote:school lunch program