Pescakl1 wrote:
I found other sellers on ebay, which brings me this question:
You bought the ABS chrome door handles, but there are also Stainless steel polished to be chrome like (manufactured by QAA).Anyone knows who manufacture the ABS set?
To my surprise, the stainless steel version is cheaper than the ABS one
What anyone think of the stainless steel version? Any fear that it could rust/deteriorate with time (if it is not really stainless steel)?
If you had the choice, same price, which one will you pick?
Generally speaking, I think that the shape and form for a good door handle cover to be made in metal, it would have to be forged or cast. Laser cutting is a possibility, but for something three dimensional it seems highly unlikely. At a price point lower than the plastic counterpart, the product almost certainly has to be stamped or pressed (the other metal fabrication techniques would cost more than plastic), and in my opinion a complex form like this will never be as good when made from stamped metal compared to molded plastic.
The likelihood for it to oxidize, I don't know; I think that a truly stainless steel alloy would be very, very stiff and even stamping or pressing it should end up costing more than a plastic counterpart (lots of pressure and precision needed); that, or the final product is not well formed.
I personally don't have much issue with chrome-finish plastic. Hell, the stock door handle is plastic as it is, only painted!
-Ed
EDIT: PS the site I linked also has the steel door handle covers that you mentioned (at least I think it would be the same as the eBay ones--maybe I'm wrong), and judging by the pictures it is a pretty good looking product, and laser cut, so I suppose I should take back my initial reservations with them, but looking at the image on this page, it doesn't have the cutouts for the smart key entry buttons, so it's only going to work with S models (there's no option on the site anywhere for a kit with the cutouts for the buttons). Perhaps the eBay ones are different though, so I'm not sure. Could you link us?
PPS: Btw, judging by the looks of it in the picture (with a whole lot of help from my spacial skills), it would appear that the laser cut steel item is a lot thinner than the plastic ones I have, so that can be a good thing or a bad thing depending on what you prefer. It won't increase the physical profile of your handles as much as the ABS plastic kit I have, but at the same time it doesn't have the, "depth," of the ABS plastic kit, which is smoother, curvier, and fills in better (for example look where the keyhole is; the steel one just has a circular cutout, but the ABS kit I have actually has a recessed portion and slides partway into the keyhole to hide more of the body color from the original handles).
PPPS: For the purposes of this discussion, here are better pics of my ABS kit (click a pic to blow it up):Front Door HandleRear Door Handle
Modified by EddNog at 8:53 PM 10/6/2008