Post by
Bubba1 »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/bubba1-u2509.html
Sun Aug 14, 2016 1:19 pm
A few thoughts. The Highlander is smaller than the other vehicles you mentioned and is essentially an SUV bodied Camry. So I agree, It's bland, but It does get better gas mileage and is probably the most reliable vehicle on your list, well, besides the Sequoia. I understand this newest version of the Durango is probably Chrysler's best ever, but that's not really saying a lot. I think you'll find Dodge/ Chrysler vehicles are thoughtfully designed and nice to drive especially when new. But that is offset by below average build quality and cheap components. It doesn't suck but I think it's a better vehicle to lease rather than buy. And depreciation tends to hit Durangos very hard. Good if you're buying one used, sucks if you're selling one. If the Pilot feels cheap, then perhaps you might consider the Acura MDX. It has a nicer personality yet based on the same platform. I have a good friend with one and have driven his a few times. It's V6 Is nice and torquey and is very comfortable. That MDX had a 6 speed automatic. I understand the newest ones have a 9 speed, I can't vouch for the 9, but that 6 speed was good. If you're planning to keep your next SUV years beyond the warranty, I would humbly suggest the MDX or Sequoia. Those two seem to stand out above the others. You'll find they cost more to buy but they hold their values better than their competition, and are more reliable on average. So if you want potentially less drama over a long period of time, they are compelling choices.
I faced a similar dilemma many years ago when I sought a new family SUV. Back then it came down to the Toyota 4 Runner and Ford Explorer. The Explorer was cheaper and had more luxury features. But I went for the more expensive Toyota. And after 17 yrs and a quarter million reliable miles I think I made the right choice.
Good luck with your choice.