I am a rep for a major oil company and "ampsucker" has hit the nail on the head with the attached quote...go with what works for you! But here's some backup for ampsucker...
Synthetics and standard motor oils have similarities and differences that force you to choose based on your needs. The main issue with leakage comes from the fact that a lot of seals are petroleum based. Like attracts like, so the petroleum in a standard motor oil naturally gets pulled into the petroleum based seals, causing them swell slightly. This is fine, no leaks, etc. However, when you change to a synthetic, which without going into too much depth, will pull the swollen seal closer to its original shape/diameter/size, subsequently causing leaks in some instances but not in every case...typically you will only see leaks in older or high-mileage vehicles. Newer/more modern seals are being manufactured to prevent this issue as synthetics become more and more popular so the chances of you experiencing it are getting slimmer.
On a personal note...I believe it is up to the consumer, their budget, their driving habits, and of course their maintenance concerns. I run traditional 5W30 as the owner's manual states...changing my own oil every 3K with an OEM filter...but I don't do aftermarket mods...my G is fast enough for me...I don't race the minivans or Civics, I drive mostly highway, etc...so like I said, everyone has different needs based on their situation.
ampsucker wrote:i think it depends on what works well for the specific engine.
the theory behind synthetic is good. all the molecules are the same size so that improves consistency and there isn't any carbon breakdown so very little chance to make sludge.
the downside is that in some engines it will cause leakage or burning for the same reason it is a good lube - it can flow very well into tiny spaces.
i run mobil 1 full syn all the time in my 04 tundra truck with an interval of 5k. no problems and it supposedly adds tenths to my mpg rate. on my older 240, i tried it and it leaked like crazy so i switched back to castrol. the older seals and such just couldn't handle it.
so, i would say, if testing has been done and there is a general consensus on the board for a certain type of oil with a certain engine, that would be the one to go with.
theory is all well and good but in the end it's all about what works in the field. ;-)