Former car, 1998 Olds Intrigue with 86,000 miles. Basic reason for replacement was desire for a higher-MPG car for commuting, and the concerns about the problems likely to start popping up as the Olds aged. My wife's car is a Lexus RX-300, and I also still own an '84 Nissan 720 pickup that gets driven whenever I buy a big load at Home Depot.
My main goal was to pick out a car that matched my daily commute, which is a twenty mile round trip, with some open 50 MPH stretches, but a lot of 35 MPH in-town stop-and-go. To me, cars are just transportation... I didn't care that much about color or styling, it just had to provide reliable, comfortable, and safe transportation. THIS is my sporty vehicle...
http://www.bowersflybaby.com/pix/moonr1.JPG
I test-drove the Toyota Yaris and Honda Fit on the same day I bought the Versa. Bought a Versa SL with CVT and the convenience package.
What I gave up:
1. Some driving comfort. The Versa's steering wheel is uncomfortably far away from my torso...I have long legs, but an average-size torso and arms. Just can't seem to find a happy medium. I've found an acceptable combination of seat-back angle and seat position, but it's still a bit of a stretch. But as the Yaris and Fit both showed the same problem, this wasn't a factor in my selection.
2. Handling. The Intrigue is a poor-man's sports sedan. It's a bit lower, and a lot wider than the Versa. It handles pretty good...I darn near ran off the road in the Versa when I tried to take it around some corners that my Olds handled nicely. Not a factor, since handling wasn't a part of my selection criteria (all cars corner equally well in stop-and-go traffic...).
3. Acceleration. This is the biggest thing I miss. I don't punch it often, but when I do, I generally need it. The Versa has an odd acceleration profile; it's actually pretty fast off the line, but acceleration then seems to sag for a few seconds until it gets to 25 MPH or so. Then it takes off nicely.
Where this bites is trying to turn out of a parking lot onto a busy road. I prefer to "punch it" to not force the oncoming drivers to hit their brakes, but the Versa just doesn't hack it, compared to most of my previous cars.
While a slight irritation, it hasn't been that much of an issue. I learned to drive on a 1964 VW Beetle (36 HP!), and I find I'm easily slipping back to the low-power habits.
Also, this lack of acceleration is NOT a disappointment...I noticed it during my test drives, and bought the car fully aware of its acceleration limits. The Yaris seemed to accelerate better, and the Fit was about the same.
4. Center Console. Rather than the tilt-up variety, I would have preferred a fixed deep console. The Olds had a retractable cup holder on the front of a deep center console, which is far more convenient than the forward-mounted holders on the Versa.
Otherwise, the overall storage space is about the same as my Olds...a pretty good situation, when you consider the difference in the car's sizes. However, I did get spoiled on the Yaris...that beast has storage EVERYWHERE.
5. Convenience features: Two things my Olds had that I wish the Versa did...and, in fact, am surprised it doesn't have. The first is automatic door locks. In the Olds, all the doors locked when I shifted into Drive. In this day and age, a desired safety feature. The second was automatic headlights. It's been a bit of a pain to train myself to remember to turn the lights on at night. :-)
6. Aft visibility. It's probably just because the car's narrower, but the rear view mirror seems to have a narrow field of vision. The outside mirrors, too, seem small and don't provide as good of coverage as my Olds did.
All right...what do I LIKE about the Versa?
A. Driving a small car again. While the Olds handled better, the Versa has it beat all to heck in a crowded parking lot. My wife has started hijacking the Versa for trips where it's tough to find parking for her Lexus.
B. The Intelligent Key System. Was totally spoiled by it in less than a week. It *is* refreshing not to have to dig the keys or the key fob out of the pocket every time you want to drive.
C. The Omnivorous CD system. I love the ability to play both conventional CDs as well as MP3 CDs. Now, if I could just figure out how to get the Versa to recognize the custom playlists on the MP3s I crank out....
D. The roominess. I am still shocked at how the Versa can carry four full-sized adults. My Olds could, but one had to set the front seats forward a bit.
E. The ride. While it doesn't ride as good as my Oldsmobile did, it's a pretty good ride for a small car. Very quiet, too. This was the deciding factor between the Yaris and the Versa; the Nissan just seemed more comfortable.
F. The CVT. I *do* like the way the car drives with the CVT. I've got an Altima as a loaner while the dealer tries to figure out the TPMS, and the difference is real apparent.
G. Mileage. I am a bit disappointed in my Versa's mileage, as it only gets ~6 MPG better than my Oldsmobile, when driven over the same commute with the same style. Still...it *is* getting about 30% higher mileage than the Olds, and the highway mileage is significantly better.
Anyway, the Versa is doing what I expected of it...can't ask for much more than that.
Ron