used/new car suggestions

[austinsG]

Hey guys second post here. I'm really looking hard at the G37 but I was thinking about other options that I might have.

The car has to be sedan or estate RWD maaaybe AWDUnfortunately it has to be an automatic because of my fiance low mileage if used like under 10,000 miles

here are my choices

RWDG37 G8 GT (really iffy on this one because of the resale and what not)Genesis V6 or V8IS350am I forgetting any other cars?

AWDMazdaSpeed6EvoWRXLegacy

[jmcohen23]

the G37 comes in AWD too (G37x).

clearly your top options are lexus and infiniti.

although I am a big fan of buying only used cars, finding a used G37 with under 10k miles will only save you about $2k on the purchase price compared to a new one.

additionally, the IS250 is available in AWD, and has the manual paddle shifters (pretty fun). so that it can be driven has an automatic or manual.

do the comparison on MSN Autos, you can compare any cars on that website.

I have driven both, and think that the infiniti offers more muscle, but the Lexus is slightly more reliable. however, the Lexus will cost more (but the resale value will whold better).

[kmckis1029]

if i had known about the G8 when i first was looking for my car last year.. i would definatly test drove it... but then again i wanted AWD... but i love how poniac does their interiors of their cars... they just show off technology and buttons... females love it

but i would definatly get a g37 over a G8... or the IS250... I see you didnt even mention a bmw...lol

[austinsG]

my price range is $30k usd so bmw's are out...

I think I narrowed it down to the G37 and IS350.

i know this is an infiniti forum but what are your honest opinions and am i leaving any cars out?

btw how do you like your 7 sp automatics? I know they rev match downshift, but how about the IS350? do they rev match as well?

[Sentientbydesign]

my price range is $30k usd so bmw's are out...

I think I narrowed it down to the G37 and IS350.

i know this is an infiniti forum but what are your honest opinions and am i leaving any cars out?

btw how do you like your 7 sp automatics? I know they rev match downshift, but how about the IS350? do they rev match as well?

There was a very active member on the boards who had a G35 and traded it for a RWD IS250. I know you're looking at the IS350, but you might try emailing him as he has direct experience with both cars.

I can't remember his screenname at the moment. I want to say Big Will, but that sounds slightly off.

Of the cars you mentioned, I personally like the WRX the most. The last one I drove was a brand new 07 and my only gripe was how high it sat and how soft the suspension was. Both of which can be fixed with aftermarket suspension or getting an 08 (when they switched the the STI suspension).

I drove manual and the transmission was like salt water taffy, firm and smooth. I haven't driven a G37(x) so I can't speak for that car. I do know that the 08 G35 Sedan is extremely comfortable and overall well thought out.

I still would prefer boost and AWD right now though. Also, stay away from the Evo. It's somewhat lack luster in performance (stock) and the crash test ratings are HORRIBLE.

[jmcohen23]

also, why would you want AWD? the car only goes AWD under 11 MPH. so unless you get a lot of snow or got some mountains to ascend, AWD is not a necessity.

[Sentientbydesign]

also, why would you want AWD? the car only goes AWD under 11 MPH. so unless you get a lot of snow or got some mountains to ascend, AWD is not a necessity.

You replied to me...I assume this was in response to the OP?

Subaru and Evo AWD are all time, not only under 11 mph like the Infiniti.

[pfarmer]

Hey guys second post here. I'm really looking hard at the G37 but I was thinking about other options that I might have.

The car has to be sedan or estate RWD maaaybe AWDUnfortunately it has to be an automatic because of my fiance low mileage if used like under 10,000 miles

here are my choices

RWDG37 G8 GT (really iffy on this one because of the resale and what not)Genesis V6 or V8IS350am I forgetting any other cars?

AWDMazdaSpeed6EvoWRXLegacy

Mercedes (some good dealing going on right now), BMW 3 series (including the high performing D), BMW 5 series (if used), and you may want to look at the new 2010 Buick (which sounds odd for younger people but this Buick is not your fathers either).

Perry

[pippen99]

I think you should consider the G8. Gm is closing out the line and you can get a fully loaded G8 GT for close to 28K. Don't worry about the warranty being honored, part of the bankruptcy deal is to honor all warranties. I like the styling of the G8 GT. Not sure why you would want AWD in Los Angeles other than you just want it. The worst thing I can see is if your the type that doesn't keep a car long the resale value might take a hit

[joe603]

although I am a big fan of buying only used cars, finding a used G37 with under 10k miles will only save you about $2k on the purchase price compared to a new one.

I disagree. There was a member who found a G37 for 6k off new with under 5k miles. Search around for a slightly used Infiniti.

I also purchased my 05 G35 coupe for 31k...New 06's were 38k+...it had under 5k miles.

[austinsG]

guys I found out that BMW have s***ty resale so I'm seriously thinking about getting a certified 335i for $27k with under 20k miles!

good idea or bad?

[Graflo]

I think we all agree the G is the best.... Unbiased opinion of course. But my last car was a Volvo S60 AWD. It was slow as hell but it was a very good car that I put 50K on without any major service... Bought it with 50K so it was the "trouble miles" for my past cars.

The AWD was the seller for me I lived on the side of a mountain in a town that didn't plow anything less than a foot of snow. The thing was a tank but it just didn't have the pep. You can find used ones really cheap and they are loaded with luxury car options.

The new Acura TL is nice and fast, the interior is sweet and they have the AWD. The only thing is you will have to buy an aftermarket grill unless you enjoy driving around a shovel. That thing is fugly... But they look good with some of the aftermarket grills I have seen.

[pfarmer]

I think we all agree the G is the best.... Unbiased opinion of course. But my last car was a Volvo S60 AWD. It was slow as hell but it was a very good car that I put 50K on without any major service... Bought it with 50K so it was the "trouble miles" for my past cars.

The AWD was the seller for me I lived on the side of a mountain in a town that didn't plow anything less than a foot of snow. The thing was a tank but it just didn't have the pep. You can find used ones really cheap and they are loaded with luxury car options.

The new Acura TL is nice and fast, the interior is sweet and they have the AWD. The only thing is you will have to buy an aftermarket grill unless you enjoy driving around a shovel. That thing is fugly... But they look good with some of the aftermarket grills I have seen.

I tend to not agree about the 'G' being the best, although on paper it looks like it is. I would go with a beemer 3 series (D or G) or with a series 5, 6, or 7. If used there are some real bargins on some high performance Mercedes including some very late model AMGs.

Perry

[jmcohen23]

guys I found out that BMW have s***ty resale so I'm seriously thinking about getting a certified 335i for $27k with under 20k miles!

good idea or bad?

actually, Beamers are one of the best when it comes to holding their value for resale. infinitis typically sell for less on resale, that is why they remain so competitive with BMW.

[docboy]

Search for one of my prior threads about the IS. Screw the IS250 AWD, HUGE financial mistake. I have an 09 IS250 AWD I'm trying to dump. Awful bump in the middle console driver's area is so darn uncomfortable; causes pain and numbness to my right leg, hip, and foot. Can't drive for more than 3 min before pain starts.

I'm looking at the G37x, TL-AWD, and Audi A4 for my replacement, but am still undecided. The 335xi is also one to consider, but I'm not sure of the turbo's reliability.

All with its own merits; it'll be a tough choice IMHO. Good luck!

[pfarmer]

Search for one of my prior threads about the IS. Screw the IS250 AWD, HUGE financial mistake. I have an 09 IS250 AWD I'm trying to dump. Awful bump in the middle console driver's area is so darn uncomfortable; causes pain and numbness to my right leg, hip, and foot. Can't drive for more than 3 min before pain starts.

I'm looking at the G37x, TL-AWD, and Audi A4 for my replacement, but am still undecided. The 335xi is also one to consider, but I'm not sure of the turbo's reliability.

All with its own merits; it'll be a tough choice IMHO. Good luck!

Except for maybe the AWD part, I have been looking at the XF(and R), especially after getting a good look at one in person.

Perry

[Poyzinous]

From what my BMW buddies have told me, the turbos have been pretty good. Its the rest of the motor and electrical system that has been unreliable and glitchy. The 2010 model should have those issues solved. But then, the 2010 G35 will be nicer than the current one. Seems the changes warrant a third series for this second gen G. the V36-3 or something.