Post by
MinisterofDOOM »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/ministerofdoom-u16506.html
Mon Dec 22, 2008 10:19 pm
I had a similar issue where the TCU would intermittently fail leaving the car with only 3rd gear. Anytime I was not applying constant throttle, I could feel the trans "pulsing" as though it was shifting back and forth from neutral to 3rd.My car would also sometimes run perfectly normally, with self-diagnostic returning an "OK". There was a weeks-long duration wherein the car ran fine, then the problem came back. Other times it would be totally random, sometimes going from working fine to 3rd-only or the other way around spontaneously while driving.
As Rex noted, if you have access to a spare TCU, it would be a good diagnostic tool. My cause ended up being a faulty TCU, replacing it cured the problem for good. I only discovered the real cause, though, after several diagnoses looking for and replacing supposedly bad sensors, etc. If I had to do it over again knowing what I do now, I'd want to start by testing with a known good TCU. If that doesn't solve it, THEN I'd move on to testing individual sensors.Another option is to have a dealer connect a consult and run a basic diagnostic. This must be done WHILE the car is malfunctioning. DO NOT turn the car off when you take it to the dealer. Leave it running. If you turn it off and the car starts functioning correctly again when they start it back up (this happened to me more than once) the Consult won't see anything wrong. It has to be malfuctioning WHEN tested for the Consult to be able to tell if there's a TCU issue (mine showed as not communicating with the ECU in the diagnostic results).
The 3 codes you list are the same codes my car's self diagnostic was returning when broken. It also returned "AT CHECK" which I initially thought was related to the TPS error code, but in the end turned out to mean the TCU was bad (the AT CHECK error can indicate any one of a few things, as the FSM shows).
Whatever you do, don't let the dealer talk you into throwing parts at the car until you've ruled out the TCU possibility. With fairly plentiful sources for used TCUs, it's a cheaper cheaper and easier repair. That way you won't end up replacing more costly parts unless it's necessary. For instance, I replaced the TPS, and both "3" and "AT CHECK" continued appearing in AT diagnostic results, proving that the TPS error code was an error in itself.