I didn't exactly do this, but mine went something like this:
I was a happy 2005 G35x owner since Dec 2004, when last summer, the car appeared to start to die. 155K miles in Michigan became too much for the wheel bearings and some other minor things. Took it to the dealership and the repair cost was too much. So I started to quickly figure out what to do, as I still wanted another year or two out of that car. I simply loved it. This is when i quickly became acquainted with CPO, and for the first time seriously considered getting a used car. Luckily over the years of having loaner vehicles I stayed pretty familiar with the Infiniti lineup, so was dreaming of getting into an M56, but could not stomach the price tag of a new one. And, i did not want to step into the new Q50's that were coming available, to let new model bugs work themselves out. So I started looking at 2012/2013 G37's. Long story short, I found a single-owner, 2012 G37x coming off a 2-year lease with 20K miles. LOVED IT. Black on black. The increase in HP over my 2005 convinced me I didn't need an M56. Got a 4-year, .9% deal and off i went. That was last year July.
Well 3 weeks ago, I took my happy new G in for some regular maintenance, and what was staring at me in the garage area, but a 2012 M56x, black/black beauty. It practically was singing to me. single owner, 3 year lease, nary a scratch on the gorgeous paint. I could not believe my eyes. Was incredibly torn, as i was completely satisfied with the G, yet there stood my "dream car". So what does a person do when confronted with a first-world problem of this nature? Ask the dealer for an over-night test drive!
One week later, i took possession of this gorgeous '12 M56x. The reality is, i love both cars.
The '12 G37x i describe as cat-like handling, somewhat pounding ride, zippy, almost never wanting for power. I always felt 100% secure taking any turn situation, dry/wet on the road I would put myself into (some rash decisions the car actually helped me with too).
The '12 M56x i describe as softer riding, comfy, less cat-like in the handling (the dealer put new tires on the car which don't perform like my old Michelin Primacy's), bigger, heavier through turns (a bit more lumbering), but GAWD, limitless power. I haven't driven a ton of crazy powered cars (I had a '97 Mustang Cobra that paled in comparison)...reminds me of an older Dodge Viper i drove while back.
Bottom line, no regrets (except the bluetooth audio display and connectivity has all kinds of problems i hope get resolved with some firmware patch that hasn't been applied).