maxnix wrote:1.) I think this statement demands a detailed and quantifiable definition of "good."
2.) Reeaaallly? I don't think so! Ticking sounds and VC gasket conditions are not related!
Just reporting my own experience here. Before I replaced my valve cover gaskets on my Q I was hearing a ticking sound coming from the engine.
A good transmission is good enough. Most of the cars that we are driving now have good transmissions in them. Meaning you can take my old transmission from my car and put it in yours and drive many years on it if you know how to maintain it.