Post by
Chaotic_Warlord »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/chaotic-warlord-u26051.html
Tue Jul 05, 2011 5:26 pm
Here's the thing with Top Gear US, Rutledge Wood is a radio and print guy and he knows NASCAR and that's about it. Adam Ferrara is a car guy in the same capacity that your dads are car guys, he knows about old school muscle and might even be a shade tree mechanic but only to a point and even that is pushing it. Tanner is a real deal car guy, he knows how to drive, has been known to help turn a wrench with his pit crew and he knows cars in every price range, plus he used to have a show test driving supercars on Speed so he knows how to host a show, he just lacks any real substance or personality to host a show. Frankly, if they had opted for Adam Carolla and any of the editors from Motor Trend or Road and Track and maybe a writer for any of the numerous other car magazines I think the show would flow smoother. The secret of the success of Top Gear UK is that all Clarkson and May both got their start writing reviews and articles in car magazines and Hamster was a Radio DJ, so all 3 knew how to entertain and inform at the same time, the chemistry helps, but it's their background and knowledge that really sell the show. Top Gear US doesn't have any of those things. The Car Show however uses the same formula as Top Gear UK, they have a radio DJ (Adam, who really knows his cars) and 2 car reviewers, the only difference is they have John Salley, who frankly is the odd man out, but he is what will give it the Sports Center feel, which is informative and entertaining. Should be some good stuff.