MarkEmark wrote:
1)It's impossible to know for sure if it was merely the viscosity or the nature of synthetic oil.
2)5W 30 is the NISSAN recommended oil for all temperatures, so 5W 30 is all I ever run. Perhaps I could have tried using a thicker mobil 1 but I wanted to use the NISSAN recommended viscosity.
3)I'm just giving my PERSONAL (not hearsay) experience.
1)No its not impossible, as Mobil1 5w-30 is nearly a 20 weight oil, during running temps and these "leaking" complaints, come mostly from Mobil1 30 weight users
2) They are assuming a dino oil and in a Dino oil year around ( they dont trust american consumers to change oil weights with seasons anymore, like they used to) and you need a 5w- to assure decent start-up when its cold.
In order to accomplish a 5w-30 vs a 10w-30 you will have a less stable oil as the bigger viscosity range is accomplished via adding polymeric thickeners.These themselves decompose and turn into varnish in your engine, as well as thinning out your oil ,as you are losing them to thermal decomposition.
This is the single greatest contributor to varnish in modern engines..
So you want as few VII's like this as possible.
Why its <always> a better choice ,to go with 10w-30 vs a 5w-30, unless your in middle of a northern winter. (and if you have an application that needs high 8-mid 11's Cst viscosity at 212F oil temp)
Nissan oil recommendation is for a NEW + Unmodified nissan engines, nearly all engines here have lots of miles = different viscosity requirements
<Also> keep in mind you are posting in the KAT forum, unless stated otherwise ,an oil recommednation will always have to be for a aftermarket turbocharged engine.that means the owners manual flys out the window, since you now need to account for lubrication need of a turbo <and> changed lubrication needs of the engine itself ( due to higher temps)\
3)Mark the attitude I detect, is uncalled for.I will always give you the right information, what you do with it, is up to you.
Fred..