From what I know of LEDs and electrical theory, what makes some LEDs dimmable with the factory dimmer, and some others will stay constant; is whats called forward voltage. This is basically the voltage that goes into the bulb. Obviously, the factory bulbs (incadecent/fillament type) have a baseline forward voltage of 12 volts. When you turn the dimmer, less voltage goes to the bulbs, making them dimmer... probly down to 7 or 8 volts I would guess... maybe a little less 'cause the Q45 can get dark! Now all the LEDs I've found have very low forward voltage, 2 volts or less usually. This means that you must use a resistor to bring the 12 car volts down to the 1 or 2 volts that the LEDs need. (see "Ohm's Law" ) Some LED have Vf of up to 5 volts, but they still won't dim with the dimmer. Best case scenario that you get some LEDs with a Vf of 5 volts, and for some silly reason you don't use a resistor, they still won't be dimmable. Now we get down to the simple mathmatics of it: if the best-case-scenario 5Vf LEDs are connected to your 12 source, they are still only going to accept 5 of those volts to function at makimum brightness. So, with your dimmer all the way down there is still way more voltage than the 5Vf that the LEDs need to funciton at maximum brightness. So therefore, the LED's don't even know the difference when you turn the dimmer up or down.
Another scenario which is most common: you get some LEDs with a Vf of 1 to 3 volts, and use the correct resistor so you don't burn them up in ten minutes. Now sorry for the Barney lesson, but this is helpful to know. With the CORRECT resistor, the commonly used LEDs will only have the 1 to 3 volts going into them. So whether you have the dimmer on full (12-13 volts) or all the way down (7 or 8 volts), there is still way more voltage than the resistor needs to still get the full voltage to the LEDs, making them function on full brightness.
The interesting thing I noticed while examining the specs sheets on superbrightleds.com is that their LED bulbs for car interiors have a forward voltage ( Vf ) of 12 volts. This means that they will opperate at maximum brightness at 12 volts. So whenever you turn down the dimmer, those LEDs will dim like factory!!!
It's easy to get sidetracked here and I can see the questions comming. "But I thought LEDs use less electricity than factory bulbs??" Well yeah. Even though the ones on superbrightleds.com have a Vf of 12 volts like the factory fillament bulbs, you have to remember that power use is measured in watts and amps. The LEDs, no matter what the Vf is, are still using only fractions of the watts that the factory bulbs are using, which frees up a little bit of stress on the factory wiring/alternator/battery. Realistically, if you changed all your bulbs (except headlights of course) with LEDs then you could dramatically reduce the power consumption of your lighting system. Here's a real-world application to help that concept make sense: in your house there's 120 volts at every wall socket. If you change all the light bulbs in your house from 60watt light bulbs to 40watt light bulbs, you could stand to see a good savings in your power bill. Here's yet another real-world application for you car audio guys!! Lets say you buy an amp for your regular 10inch subwoofer, and the amp is rated at 400 watts. Nothing special, sounds good and your headlights don't dim out when the bass hits. Soon you want more and then you get a big fat sub and a matching amp that uses 1100 watts. Now you're gonna have some lighting issues when the bass hits.
Well this post was a little long-winded, but hopefully it clears up some of the confusion about LEDs. It took me years to sort throught all the b/s and come up with an understanding. If you don't want to search for the dimmable LEDs (12 Vf) or if you don't want/need them to dim then you can learn more about Ohm's Law and how to calculate the resistor size you will need for a given LED's Vf, check out this posting in The12Volt
http://www.the12volt.com/insta...&PN=1