Still running LEAN at idle...

Your premier source for information on the Turbo KA: KA24E-T and KA24DE-T (KA with aftermarket turbo kit)!
User avatar
rn240sx
Posts: 891
Joined: Mon Jan 05, 2004 6:15 pm
Car: 12 Frontier V6 (supercharged)
98 240sx ka-t (fully built)
09 Ninja 650R
06 Suzuki S40
15 Hyundai Santa-Fe 2.0T
Contact:

Post

Ok, I removed the MSD box, but the stock distributor back on and put my 6 heat range plugs back in, the motor idle's SMOOTH and have no hesitation at all... Boost comes on quick and no more throttle problems...

But here is the other deal. Im still running 19.9 on the wideband at idle. I have to tune the afc to +50 to get the a/f at 14-15 for it to run smooth..

Is this an indication that the narrowband output from the wideband has gone bad..??

I can swap out the wideband for the regular O2 sensor, but thats like an hour job for a 30 second swap..

b4 i do this i wana be sure that the 02 sensor is the main culprit for this lean idle mixture...

What else can cause this lean mixture at idle..??


:: orion ::
Posts: 1483
Joined: Fri May 23, 2003 4:40 pm
Car: '96 240SX, with KA-T @ 12psi...
Contact:

Post

O2 sensor is ignored at idle and WOT...

Check your fuel pressure...(?)

- Brian

User avatar
WDRacing
Moderator
Posts: 15983
Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2002 2:00 am
Car: 95 240SX, 99 BMW 540i, 01 Chevy Express, 14 Ford Escape
Location: MFFO
Contact:

Post

Huh, I thought it was WOT only. Learn somthin everyday.

s13sr20chris
Posts: 4148
Joined: Tue Jun 10, 2003 9:32 am
Car: '89 Nissan S13 w/redtop running 13psi and not leaking fuel anymore
Contact:

Post

where are you reading your a/f?

if that really is your a/f the car should idle bad.

User avatar
rn240sx
Posts: 891
Joined: Mon Jan 05, 2004 6:15 pm
Car: 12 Frontier V6 (supercharged)
98 240sx ka-t (fully built)
09 Ninja 650R
06 Suzuki S40
15 Hyundai Santa-Fe 2.0T
Contact:

Post

s13sr20chris wrote:where are you reading your a/f?

if that really is your a/f the car should idle bad.
Where, ahh from my wideband O2 which is on the downpipe...

Yes it DOES idle bad as i stated b4, UNLESS i tune the afc +50 % so that i can get it to 14-15... then it idle's perfect.

But there shouldnt be any reason to mess with the afc to get it at that a/f ratio during idle... Ive never had this problem b4..

User avatar
uncle_louie83
Posts: 242
Joined: Sat Apr 02, 2005 12:19 pm
Car: 1993 Nissan 240sx Coupe

Post

at idle your a/f ratio will bounce back and fourth between lean and rich....all my turbo cars have done this and all my all motor cars have too.

lewis

User avatar
rn240sx
Posts: 891
Joined: Mon Jan 05, 2004 6:15 pm
Car: 12 Frontier V6 (supercharged)
98 240sx ka-t (fully built)
09 Ninja 650R
06 Suzuki S40
15 Hyundai Santa-Fe 2.0T
Contact:

Post

uncle_louie83 wrote:at idle your a/f ratio will bounce back and fourth between lean and rich....all my turbo cars have done this and all my all motor cars have too.

lewis
Yeah thats on a standard narrowband a/f gauge.. A Wideband does not do that. Mine since day one has been solid at 14.6 at idle and has gotten worse over time and i cant figure out why. Even with tunning the afc to +50%... its not helping anymore. Now its gotten to the point where i sound like i have lumpy cams and the car will barely idle..!!

User avatar
S14tat
Posts: 714
Joined: Thu Aug 29, 2002 11:39 am
Car: 2007 FX35
1994 Acura NSX
1996 Honda Accord coupe
1995 S14 KA-T *sold*

Post

i remember anthony's wideband 02 sensor went bad like last year. it was driving him nuts casue he couldn't figure out why he running 12-13:1 afr no matter how much he tuned it at WOT.

he said the main symptoms for a bad wideband 02 sensor is that it would not read the extremes on both ends. that means that at first it wouldn't go to AIR or RICH. then it wouldn't go to 19:1 or 10:1 then 18:1 or 11:1 and so on. the range it would read gradually gets smaller and smaller

i think the reason why his failed was because he runs alot of race gas and race gas leaves that white film in your tail pipe. do you run alot of race gas?

User avatar
rn240sx
Posts: 891
Joined: Mon Jan 05, 2004 6:15 pm
Car: 12 Frontier V6 (supercharged)
98 240sx ka-t (fully built)
09 Ninja 650R
06 Suzuki S40
15 Hyundai Santa-Fe 2.0T
Contact:

Post

S14tat wrote:i think the reason why his failed was because he runs alot of race gas and race gas leaves that white film in your tail pipe. do you run alot of race gas?
I run 100 octane (cam 2) un-leaded gas all the time cause 93 pump limits me to ~14 psi. This car is not a dailr driver, its my weekend street racer so i dont even bother running pump anymore. Since im always pushing over 14 psi when im racing...

User avatar
S14tat
Posts: 714
Joined: Thu Aug 29, 2002 11:39 am
Car: 2007 FX35
1994 Acura NSX
1996 Honda Accord coupe
1995 S14 KA-T *sold*

Post

does your wideband show extremes on either end of hte spectrum though? like dead rich or dead lean?

User avatar
emperor_lunchbox
Posts: 1305
Joined: Sun Feb 22, 2004 6:31 am
Car: 91 240sx, 96 eclipse spyder, and 96 camaro z28 (For Sale)

Post

off topic rn240sxwhere are you in orlando?

User avatar
rn240sx
Posts: 891
Joined: Mon Jan 05, 2004 6:15 pm
Car: 12 Frontier V6 (supercharged)
98 240sx ka-t (fully built)
09 Ninja 650R
06 Suzuki S40
15 Hyundai Santa-Fe 2.0T
Contact:

Post

S14tat wrote:does your wideband show extremes on either end of hte spectrum though? like dead rich or dead lean?
Well, when i let the pedal go (closing the throttle plate to decelerate) the wideband goes to LEAN 19.9 and stays there for a while until the car comes to a stop, then it will jump back to mid 14's... This i think is new and i dont recall it ever dropping to dead lean like that b4... Or maybe i just didnt pay too much attention to it when i come off throttle... so it may be normal..

Also when i 1st hit the gas pedal, it will go to pig rich for a split second then go to mid 14's as normal if im in vacuum mode..

Hope that was what u were looking for...
emperor_lunchbox wrote:off topic rn240sxwhere are you in orlando?
Im on the border of orlando and kissimmee. Hunters creek community. John Young and Deerfield.

User avatar
S14tat
Posts: 714
Joined: Thu Aug 29, 2002 11:39 am
Car: 2007 FX35
1994 Acura NSX
1996 Honda Accord coupe
1995 S14 KA-T *sold*

Post

hmmm then it seems like your wideband is working fine. but whats odd to me is that when your letting off, it read lean. haha even though mine is recirculated, it still reads RICH when i let off then it stablizes it self. thats why whenever i go to the dyno, when they let off, theres a big puff of black smoke.

anyone else can chime in here and see what the car is suppose to do when you let off on boost? or just letting off the throttle in general?

Structure240sx
Posts: 5615
Joined: Sun Oct 06, 2002 5:04 pm

Post

my jwt ecu is the same way at idle. i have +50% on my safc for idle

User avatar
S14tat
Posts: 714
Joined: Thu Aug 29, 2002 11:39 am
Car: 2007 FX35
1994 Acura NSX
1996 Honda Accord coupe
1995 S14 KA-T *sold*

Post

did it go up? i remembered you having to go like +27 before or something like that becsaue i'm at +25 on idle. or did i just remember it wrong?

User avatar
DammitBobby
Posts: 1431
Joined: Fri May 02, 2003 5:41 am
Car: S13 91 KA24DET
Contact:

Post

Well, when i let the pedal go (closing the throttle plate to decelerate) the wideband goes to LEAN 19.9 and stays there for a while until the car comes to a stop

I have JWT ECU 72lbs program, SAFCII and mine will go 21 when I let off the pedal and will stay there until I reach stop point. I turned my DEC setting to 0 because the bov is recirculated. I know I have to richen mine as well at idle because it will read around 18:1 and wont idle. I think I have mine set to around +30% at 1k. When I had a open atmosphere BOV I had to turn mine all the way up to +50%.

S14tatI don`t have any black smoke when I let off the pedal.

User avatar
rn240sx
Posts: 891
Joined: Mon Jan 05, 2004 6:15 pm
Car: 12 Frontier V6 (supercharged)
98 240sx ka-t (fully built)
09 Ninja 650R
06 Suzuki S40
15 Hyundai Santa-Fe 2.0T
Contact:

Post

DammitBobby wrote:Well, when i let the pedal go (closing the throttle plate to decelerate) the wideband goes to LEAN 19.9 and stays there for a while until the car comes to a stop

I have JWT ECU 72lbs program, SAFCII and mine will go 21 when I let off the pedal and will stay there until I reach stop point. I turned my DEC setting to 0 because the bov is recirculated. I know I have to richen mine as well at idle because it will read around 18:1 and wont idle. I think I have mine set to around +30% at 1k. When I had a open atmosphere BOV I had to turn mine all the way up to +50%.

S14tat

I don`t have any black smoke when I let off the pedal.
I guess im NOT the only person with this IDENTICAL MIRROR image problem..!!! Thats 3 of us with this problem and all of us are running the jwt ecu with over 370cc inj program. I didnt have this problem with the 370cc program..

Well i guess its normal and there is nothing physically bad... Just have to either deal with it or dump jwt.

User avatar
S14tat
Posts: 714
Joined: Thu Aug 29, 2002 11:39 am
Car: 2007 FX35
1994 Acura NSX
1996 Honda Accord coupe
1995 S14 KA-T *sold*

Post

yeah when i first had the JWT, it freaked me out. i was like wtf is going on, why won't the thing idle. i had it sent back twice for inspection. then i'm just like F.. that i wanna run more then 10 psi so i just band aided with my safc. as it turns out like a few weeks later, anthony got his JWT program back and he had to do the same thing.

and dammnitbobby, i see mine is the one thats alittle weird. hmmmm we'll as long as it doesn't stall and i'm still getting 21+ mpg i'm fine. but thats definitly something i should look into when i'm really bored.

User avatar
DammitBobby
Posts: 1431
Joined: Fri May 02, 2003 5:41 am
Car: S13 91 KA24DET
Contact:

Post

I have a snap shot of my data log in this threadhttp://forums.nicoclub.com/zerothread?id=161172 I tuned it this weekend.

User avatar
rn240sx
Posts: 891
Joined: Mon Jan 05, 2004 6:15 pm
Car: 12 Frontier V6 (supercharged)
98 240sx ka-t (fully built)
09 Ninja 650R
06 Suzuki S40
15 Hyundai Santa-Fe 2.0T
Contact:

Post

The bottom line is we should NOT have to use an afc to fine tune the a/f curve to stabalize the idle...That is a problem with jim wolf's tunning and it needs to be fixed. Their 370cc program is flawless at idle, why can the 550,615 and 740 programs be the same. I can understand having problems with something like 1000cc+ sized injectors especially at providing a smooth idle, but c'mon... Again, we should NOT have to use an afc to tune this...

User avatar
S14tat
Posts: 714
Joined: Thu Aug 29, 2002 11:39 am
Car: 2007 FX35
1994 Acura NSX
1996 Honda Accord coupe
1995 S14 KA-T *sold*

Post

went i sent the ecu back to them, they seem to run it on some kind of simulator, not on a actual car, and they're telling me that its the right program and that its works flawlessly on their computer. i mean how else can i argue with that right?

well thats were scott enthalpy comes in. when nissanfanatic got his tune, it started right up and almost everything was right on the money.

User avatar
DammitBobby
Posts: 1431
Joined: Fri May 02, 2003 5:41 am
Car: S13 91 KA24DET
Contact:

Post

Yep I am with you on that one idle should be the same for all programs no matter what turbo you are running. To be consistantly off that much they need to make a change to there simulator. Answer is JWT and SAFCII or Scott Enthalpy. If I had to do it again I would go with Scott I have yet to hear anything bad about his tuning abilities.

User avatar
rn240sx
Posts: 891
Joined: Mon Jan 05, 2004 6:15 pm
Car: 12 Frontier V6 (supercharged)
98 240sx ka-t (fully built)
09 Ninja 650R
06 Suzuki S40
15 Hyundai Santa-Fe 2.0T
Contact:

Post

S14tat wrote:went i sent the ecu back to them, they seem to run it on some kind of simulator, not on a actual car, and they're telling me that its the right program and that its works flawlessly on their computer. i mean how else can i argue with that right?
Flawlessly on a computer vs testing it on an actual motor are 2 totally different things. Thats their answer to "they cant fix it".

Im gonna switch to enthalpy's tune..!! There is no reason why we should have to run an afc to get smooth idle.. thats rediculous.

User avatar
klattr1
Posts: 1130
Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 1:18 pm
Car: GT42R powered S14/KA
Location: Charlotte, NC
Contact:

Post

:: orion :: wrote:O2 sensor is ignored at idle and WOT...

Check your fuel pressure...(?)

- Brian
i thought it was only ignored at WOT (open loop) and would operate in closed loop at idle and partial throttle situations.

at idle when warmed up, the 02 voltage oscillates (rich to lean)...whenever i had a bad 02 or wiring was funky, i would produce a low voltage at idle (around .33 volts steady...not oscillating like it should) and my car would in turn run rich (due to wideband readings and black sut on my rear bumper hehe).

now whats causing Robert's (rn240sx) situation...im not sure...my old cobra mafs/72lb JWT program idled very nice (around 14:1-15:1)...i imagine that if his 02 was bad and was sending a high voltage signal to the ecu, that his car could actually run leaner in result (causing some rough idling)...

i never liked the idea of using a wideband to simulate the narrowband voltage...thats why i always kept mine separate (two bungs, two different sensors)...

dont turn this into a JWT bash...even Enthalpy ecu's have had some problems...not every tune will be perfect.

BTW...both Enthalpy and JWT offer retunes...its not the end of the world.

Structure240sx
Posts: 5615
Joined: Sun Oct 06, 2002 5:04 pm

Post

im very happy with my results with my jwt


Return to “KA24ET / KA24DET Forum”