Definitely read the sticky! Also please research for info on blacktops being somewhat newer to much newer and usually price will reflect this.
The all important Red top / Black top thread:
zerothread?id=59346
Generally speaking, when you're buying an engine, you'd like to pick the newest and best condition for the price. Just like produce at the grocery store. Blacktops happen to be the newest and this translates to less wear & tear, with exceptions of course..