Welcome, Shawn.
Get the stick! Get the stick! Get the stick!
There are many happy CVT drivers, and are reliable, but i wouldn't get one if my leg fell off. The 6sp shifter is sweeter than my buddy's old Sentra SE-R 5sp and my old Sentra XE, as nice as my old VWs, and leagues ahead of all Toyotas I have rowed. Reliability? When the horn went on the Sentra, I used the rev limiter instead. Over 3000000km when sold [A/C died] to next happy owner. Nuff said.
Can I be honest about drawbacks?...
I wish it were a G35 wagonish-hatch thing, but get turbo-diesel fuel economy
Solution? Buy Versa!