Post by
RicerX »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/ricerx-u125542.html
Mon Aug 15, 2016 9:28 am
I do not own a Red Sport myself, but I have studied it extensively, and when I was buying my 2015 Q50S, I had cross-shopped the S4. I will answer your questions based on what I know:
1) I'm not a big fan of the DAS. I prefer a traditional steering system until they get a couple generations of refinement into the design. It's brand-new tech, and I'm not aware of any other automaker deploying such a system. If you'd like to have the option to tune your steering setup, it is very neat - you'll just have a risk there. In the Red Sport, it is very much improved from the first gen system in the 14-15 models. My advice is to test drive both - with and without DAS.
2) I'm on the same tires with my Q, just different rear sizes. I'd say I'm about 50% through them at 20k miles. The wheels can absolutely mount non-RF tires if you like.
3) I haven't gotten my hands on the service manual for the 16 Q50s yet, so I'm not sure. So far, I assume it's the typical 5k maintenance interval.
4) They have further revised the InTouch system for the 16s, and it got a hardware overhaul in 2015. The only severe InTouch bugs were largely relegated to the 2014 models. I don't expect much trouble there other than the quirks designed into the system. However, Android Auto is likely to make it into many Infiniti models as early as MY2017, and I'd be VERY curious to see how that changes the InTouch experience.
As far as recalls, none yet, but I'm anticipating something due to the many reports of accessory belts being sheared off of the Red Sport so far. This is the first year with a brand-new motor that hasn't ever been deployed with any vehicle before, so these things are going to happen. The rule of thumb is to not buy a clean-sheet powertrain in its first model year for obvious reasons, and that holds true with the Red Sport.
Audi has made great strides to improve reliability, but in models as new as 2014, I found many reports of transmission issues. I have not found the Audis to ever be reliable in that regard. If you've noticed, Audi has ditched the DCT offered in the outgoing S4 to go back to a traditional automatic like the Q50 starting in 2017 (or 2016? I can't remember the refresh MY for the Audi offhand.) They will also no longer offer a manual in the new S4.
The 7AT in the Q50 is pretty solid, but I know the torque rating it's built for is exceeded with the Red Sport's motor, and I'm not sure if they made revisions to the transmission to accommodate - I can't find anything definitive from Jatco or Nissan on the matter. Hopefully they have. Infiniti V6s have always been rock solid - this isn't anything new, and aside from a couple initial tweaks, I expect the 3.0TT in the Red Sport to be no exception. The Red Sport makes more power than the S4, but I haven't seen a direct comparison between the two in actual pavement delivery of said power, and how each handles. I can't imagine them being very far apart.
Styling - that's all in the eye of the beholder. I find both cars very much attractive.
Hope that provides some perspective! Good luck in your search.
When I priced my Q50S, I found myself about $7,000 apart from a comparably equipped S4 (2015 for 2015). The Red Sport and its packaging isn't much different from the 3.7L S in its pricing, so I expect the pricing difference to favor the Infiniti here.