elwesso wrote:Drew, hes right!!! The downward motion of the piston creates lower pressure in the cylinder, which then the atmospheric pressure forces into the engine... You just can't ignore the mechanicals.
The basic dynamics of fluids (yes, air is a fluid!!) is that "fluids go from where they are, to where they aint"... thats about as simple as it can be...
Consider this example. When you have a straw in your supersize drink at McDonalds and you "suck" the liquid up, you are not actually sucking in.. you are creating a pressure differential, and the atmospheric pressure is actually pressing DOWN on the surface of the soft drink, and thus FORCING it up the straw...! try sealing the lid of the cup completely to the atmosphere and sucking on the straw!! Yeah, it aint gonna happen..
Those who chose to ignore the basic rules of physics are simply fools in their right.
To counter your other arguments, when you breathe, you are not SUCKING air in. Your diaphram contracts and decreases the pressure (by increasing the volume... inside your lungs, and thus the air is forced in... When you are sitting idle (and not breathing) the pressure is exactly the same outside your lungs as it is inside...
I am sure Mr. boyle (Boyles law, pressure is inversely proportional to volume) was a complete idiot and he has no clue what hes talking about.
Similarly, as the piston moves down you are increasing the volume, you are then decreasing the pressure, and thus the air can move in.
I also agree with you, vacuum is not a good word to use, as its simply a pressure differential. Vacuum is the absense of pressure, and it really does not exist except in the far reaches of space... even near the earth in orbit there is some pressure, albiet very very minimal.....
I couldnt agree with you more!
Wes, I'm am not and cannot argue a basic law of physics... just the perception of it.
Yes air is a liquid... it just contains less of the heavier hydrogen molecules (depending on humidity) and is much lighter than lets say, water. And yes, the lung does maintain a positive air pressure inside the diaphram with relation to the atmoshphere... hence the term "collapsed lung" once a breach is realized. But you must realize the act of breathing involves expansion/contraction of the diapharam fed by the adominal and accessory muscles. Air does not just rush in. That's the active catalyst! BTW, when you are sitting idle not breathing, the lung pressure is not equal to the atmosphere else you'd be dead ...it has to maintain a positive pressure at all times else it collapses.
We all know that we are manipulating the constant (in relation to the big picture) atmospheric pressure on this green-house called earth....I'm not disputing that at all, however, there is such a thing as a catalyst or cause for the change in pressure with relation to the outside atmosphere.
Since the atmosphere remains at pressure, it's a given constant and strives to maintain equilibrium in all spaces it occupies. The downward stroke of the piston after combusting creates a vacuum/void so it becomes the active catalyst in the cause for the change in pressure with relation to the given constant. I have no problem calling this rush to equilibrum of air pressure suction anymore than I have calling the pre-existing pressure difference in the cylinder a vacuum.
I have no problem calling a duck a friggin duck!
Now I have a headache and going to ingest another liquid... BEER
...Drew....
Modified by DrewQ45 at 12:35 PM 3/19/2006