Def wrote:I think you guys are getting "technology" confused with "performance."
Sure the SR has a few bells and whistles the KA doesn't(not many that matter IMO), but when it comes to revving, the SR has a very "pedestrian" valvetrain compared to the KA. While the KA can't take advantage of its better designed valvetrain, the SR potentially could use one that could allow it to rev up really high with its relatively "rev friendly" bottom end geometry.
Both motors are a bit of a mismatch in that respect. The one that has the valvetrain to rev can't because of its long stroke, and the one that needs the valvetrain has a really poor one IMO.
The CA is a better "matched" motor IMO, but it just doesn't have the displacement for bigger power. You can only rev so high and wait so long for the turbo to boost your anemic powerband...
My only question is... why spend oodles of money for an SR swap for only about 170rwhp, then gobs more money on bolt-on after bolt-on to get up to about 240-250rwhp?
Are people missing how cheap it is to piece together a turbo kit on a KA if you have half a brain?
I understand the high mileage argument, but it's not like the SRs people are getting are factory fresh. Plus boosting on a perfectly healthy 150k mile KA is not going to kill the engine if you avoid detonation. So that seems kinda a moot point if your KA is in relatively good condition.
All the people arguing about which engine can hold 400+ rwhp are good for a laugh as well. How many people here actually make that much power? Have you ever driven a car with that much power on the streets? I don't think the example that more people are using engine X to make 500+rwhp is a good one, due to the simple fact that you can make ANY engine put out stupid amounts of power if you have enough money and a little knowhow. I guarantee you a KA could pump out 500+rwhp, there is just little point, so not many people do it.
Oh well - I guess it comes down to personal preference.
1) I make that much power. (not on my 240 tho)
2) I've driven a stock Viper on the street, as well as my Z daily during spring/summer/fall.
3) Correct, with $, just about any engine can be made for huge HP..just depends on how much $ u have.
4) Explain how "cheap" it would be to piece together a turbo kit for a KA. Please include the following items.
Turbo T3/T4Manifoldintake/exhaust/downpipeBOVIntercoolerCustom PipingFuel ManagementFuel PumpLabor (unless do it yourself)Stock Engine w/ high miles? --> rebuild ($)
Tidbits here and there, oem parts, hoses, etc etc
5) Boosting on a 150K KA engine is just asking for trouble (unless rebuilt)...I had a website with someone who tried..and blew it up.
my 3 cents