Are you mechanically inclined? You can check the status of the power valve screws yourself. Follow
this guide. Put red threadlocker on all of the screws. If any are missing, that's definitely a possible cause of your oil consumption and/or catalytic converter issues. While you have the upper and lower intake manifolds apart, replace the PCV valve with an OEM part (shouldn't be more than $16 or so). If you're confident that you can do this yourself, let me know and I'll compile a list of the necessary gaskets you'll need to replace.