P0021, P1491: possible short to ground?

A forum for the legendary Nissan Pathfinder and Infiniti QX4.
User avatar
rgk
Posts: 588
Joined: Tue Dec 23, 2014 4:48 am
Car: 02 Pathfinder LE 3.5 auto 4x4
Location: Indiana Dunes National Park

Post

I have had a P0021 plague me for a while now. I just finally replaced the cam sprocket, and the code persists. Right after buttoning everything up, I noticed some frayed wiring going to the VVT solenoid, which leads me down the electrical rabbit hole. I believe I may have a short to ground, which I am hoping someone here can confirm or deny.

I have checked continuity at the red-yellow wire that goes from battery power to the bank 2 VVT solenoid. When unplugged from the solenoid, I get about 45 ohms across the terminal and ground. This persists when I unplug the ECM, but when I unplug the circuit fuse, the resistance jumps to 1.6k ohms.

Looking at the schematic, I see that I shouldn't have a ground between this terminal and battery voltage.

Image

Also in the schematic I see that fuse 16 also houses the VIAS, swirl, throttle position, and EVAP circuits, among others.

Image

Of these, EVAP and TPS are of note. I am also suffering from a P1491, and sometimes when I open the fuel cap, I can hear air rushing in. The purpose of the EVAP vacuum cut valve bypass solenoid is to allow intake vacuum to suck on the gas tank for diagnostic purposes. However, it seems that this solenoid is getting stuck and allowing the intake to perpetually suck on gas tank vapors. I believe a short to ground would cause this, because there is no ground on this circuit aside from the ECM. In the past I have repaired frayed wires that were touching each other right beside the EVAP bypass, but that did not solve the P1491.

So how is this related to the VVT solenoid? Well, the vacuum cut valve bypass solenoid is wired directly to the EVAP purge volume control solenoid at the top of the intake. You can see this at the top of the schematic, it reads "To EC-PGC/V."

Image

The wire for the EVAP purge volume control solenoid shares shielding with the bank 2 VVT solenoid, the throttle position sensor, and throttle position switch. (Side note, I have had the TPS take out the ECU in the past, which I repaired) Looking at the TPS schematic, I see that there is a shielding wire that surrounds one of the TPS wires and goes to ground at the main timing cover ground straps (F43).

Image

So, I have a P0021 (bank 2 camshaft over-advanced) and a P1491 (vacuum cut valve bypass valve malfunction), two seemingly-unrelated problems that very conveniently share shielding. What I am thinking is that either they are shorting one another out, or they are grounding themselves on the TPS shielding. This is causing the VVT solenoid to malfunction, which is causing my cam to over-advance. It is also causing the EVAP vacuum cut valve bypass solenoid to stick open and apply vacuum to the gas tank.

Here are my typical bank 1 and 2 VVT solenoid readings. Bank 1 is the lower purple readout, whereas bank 2 is the upper blue readout. You can see that bank 1 is jumping around, presumably in response to the engine. Bank 2 stays pretty much steady.

Image

What I'd like to know is whether there is a good way to troubleshoot this further before I cut into shielding. And is my electrical diagnosis even correct? In other words, am I correct in thinking that the red-yellow wire that goes to the VVT solenoid should have infinite resistance to a ground?


User avatar
VStar650CL
Technical Expert
Posts: 11931
Joined: Thu Nov 12, 2020 1:25 pm
Car: 2013 Nissan Altima 2.5 SL
2004 Nissan Altima 2.5 S

Post

The IVT's and most of the other solenoids on the car are all straight ground-driven. The only difference between the IVT's and "on-off" solenoids like the Evap Vent is that the IVT can assume "middle" positions modulated by PWM from the ECM. PWM just means the valve is turned on and off very rapidly (usually kilohertz rates), so quickly that the solenoid sees the average voltage and not the on-off cycles. Since the IVT has 12V all the time and the ground side is modulated by the ECM, the lower the average voltage the solenoid sees, the further the hydraulic spool moves. Because it's ground-side driven, a short to ground on the ECU side of the circuit will actuate the solenoid at 100% all the time. So the short answer is yes, those wires need to read infinity to ground, but, they have to be disconnected at both ends when checking. The MOSFET driver inside the ECM will give you a ground reading if it's partially melted, which can easily fool you into thinking a blown ECM is a bad wire.

User avatar
VStar650CL
Technical Expert
Posts: 11931
Joined: Thu Nov 12, 2020 1:25 pm
Car: 2013 Nissan Altima 2.5 SL
2004 Nissan Altima 2.5 S

Post

To go a bit further, the 45 ohms you're reading from the power wire to ground is also unhealthy if you're getting that reading with all ends disconnected. You probably aren't, since there are usually a pile of other devices sharing that power circuit. Unless they're all disconnected, you'll be reading an amalgam of the resistance of various coils and devices. I doubt you'll find your issue on the power side anyway, chances are it's in the ground-side wire or the ECM. We actually see frequent ECM failures from those circuits blowing up on 2.5 and 3.5 FWD's, all have the IVT solenoids directly above the drive belt and when a belt delaminates or shreds, it "whips" the IVT wiring. If the 12V and ground-side wires contact one another for even an instant, the MOSFET in the ECM turns to burnt toast before the fuse can blow.


Return to “Nissan Pathfinder Forum / Infiniti QX4 Forum”