eeshazor wrote:I know I'm super late on this.. but are we all suggesting that the overdrive function should be left ON while I'm driving at high speeds? When overdrive is on, the car is much noisier.. which I would assume means my engine is working harder? So why would that help my fuel economy? The only time I use overdrive is when I AM going uphill; it stops me from rolling back (i.e. On La Cienega making a right turn onto Sunset Blvd. in Hollywood, CA... ridiculous hill!!)
Overdrive is simply the highest gear on most modern transmissions.
Don't think of overdrive as overdrive. Think of it as a gear, with a number, which it really is.
In a manual transmission, you have, say, 5 speeds. 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5. 5 is overdrive, but it's not usually called that. Just like any other gear, you shift into 5th gear as needed. Just pretend the term "overdrive" doesn't exist. On Nissan's 6 speed manuals, 5th AND 6th are overdrive, with 6th more overdriven than 5th.
All that applies to automatics, too, except you USUALLY don't do the shifting. But you CAN manually shift, and that's what the OD button is for. It's just the top-gear shifter position, even if it's a button instead of a shifter position. And sometimes overdrive actually IS a shifter position. You won't find an Overdrive button, switch, or label of any kind in my Q45 or LS8 (both automatics). The Q's shifter has positions for 1, 2, 3, and 4. 4 is overdrive. The LS8 has positions for 1 through 5, and 5 is overdrive.
The purpose of multiple gears is to provide a way to keep engine speed (RPM) from maxing out and limiting car speed. If you only had 1st gear, you couldn't go more than 20-something mph and even then you'd be working the engine hard and using lots of gas. So you add a gear. Now you can go a little faster without hitting redline. Add another gear and you can go faster still.
So, yes, you should be using overdrive at high speeds. That is the sole purpose of overdrive, the only reason it exists.
To address your points specifically:
The only time I use overdrive is when I AM going uphill; it stops me from rolling back
That's simply not possible. Regardless of the position of the Overdrive switch, overdrive is only ever in use when the car is in motion and travelling faster than ~35 (maybe higher for the Versa) at a constant rate (cruising) with no real acceleration load on the car. If you try to accelerate, increase throttle, or start going up even a slight incline, the transmission will shift out of overdrive for power. When stopped, the car shifts into 1st gear. Overdrive is 4th gear. It's not in use yet.
So why would that help my fuel economy?
Every time a piston fires, it uses fuel. The faster your engine is turning (RPMs) the more times per second each piston is firing. Higher engine RPMs means using more fuel. The best way to improve fuel economy is to keep RPMs as low as possible. Going back to what I said above about why cars have more than one gear in the first place, Overdrive (and every gear) is simply there to allow you to achieve greater vehicle speed without having to drastically (and for long periods of time) increase engine speed. The faster you go, the higher the gear you need to keep RPMs low. Low RPMs = less fuel consumed. The right gear to maintain your current speed is what it's all about. Finding the right mix of enough power and low RPMs. Too high a gear and the car isn't making enough power. Too low a gear and you're revving high and overworking the engine and wasting fuel.
Which brings me to my next point:
When overdrive is on, the car is much noisier.. which I would assume means my engine is working harder?
Your engine is working LESS hard, actually. But, if the car really is significantly noisier with overdrive on, you might have a problem. Just keep in mind that Overdrive ONLY APPLIES WHEN THE CAR IS ACTUALLY USING TOP GEAR. So merely leaving the O/D switch "on" doesn't affect anything at all unless you're cruising at a steady 35+. Which means the difference in noise may very well stem from something else entirely.
Really, there are only a handful of times you should ever really need to disable overdrive:
--When driving using Cruise Control on hilly terrain (to keep the transmission from "hunting" and shifting back and forth between 3rd and 4th excessively)
--When you anticipate a need to pass on the highway and want temporarily increased passing power.
--When using engine speed to slow the car (engine braking) descending a hill.
--When towing (which probably isn't an issue for most Versa owners). This goes back to the whole balancing power with efficiency thing. Towing with overdrive enabled can be very stressful on a transmission.
Aside from those, unless you're driving aggressively, the car will use or not use overdrive as it sees the need, and having that extra gear option available is only helping.
I wish cars and their manuals would do a better job of explaining how (and why) things work instead of just putting nebulous-sounding buttons and labels on things. The more people understand about what does what on their car, the better off the are. Oversimplifying things just leaves people in need of answers.
