I just changed mine over the weekend...it had around 3000 miles...the oil was not too dark. It really just depends when the last oil change was done and the miles that have been driven. It will look pretty bad at 5000 miles plus if you are using conventional motor oil.Tahoemofo wrote:It was due to be changed 4 days ago. Does in normally get so cruddy around the time change is required? I am getting it changed tomorrow and will also ask the dealer about it. Thanks.
Also - this site rocks. I got so much useful info from this site before I made my purchase. Thanks for your help.
I doubt a synthetic oil is a direct cause here. Perhaps it was a ticking time bomb so to speak and the synthetic helped it along, but it was likely to occur anyways. I've switched the last 4 cars I've owned to synthetic after it had been using conventional oil and never had any problems.BigWill wrote:I can tell you from personal experience that there seems to be an issue with using synthetic in older motors. I had a '95 BMW 525i before getting my G. The Bimmer went to my son. I had kept the oil changed in it very regularly, (3,500 to 5,000 mile intervals.) My son, once he got the car, went right away and had the oil changed, wanting to start fresh.
He did so without consulting me about what I was using. He assumed that synthetic was better in all cases. The motor had about 120k on it, and ran like a swiss clock for me. As soon as he changed to syn, the car began a HORRENDOUS ticking. He told me about it, and I told him to go right away and have his mechanic change back to dino-oil. Unfortunately, it was too late. He still has the ticking, and his mechanic told him that a lifter is sticking, and that he will have to have the top end rebuilt to eliminate it. Now, it may be a coincidence, but I don't think so. How about y'all?
I agree. It is possible the oil used had a stronger detergent that loosened up some contamination, blocking a lubrication path. But it was likely to happen eventually anyway, if that's the case.I don't think you would find many bimmers around NOT using a synthetic.C-Kwik wrote:
I doubt a synthetic oil is a direct cause here. Perhaps it was a ticking time bomb so to speak and the synthetic helped it along, but it was likely to occur anyways. I've switched the last 4 cars I've owned to synthetic after it had been using conventional oil and never had any problems.