In a truck application cast iron liners extra 2-3 pounds vs saving $300 for exotic coatings favors adding the weight:
http://www.instmat.co.uk/iom/d...3.htmh ... /5140r.htm
"Switching engine blocks from cast iron to aluminum is not quite a no-brainer, though. In 1996, BMW ran into problems in the U.S. when it began to convert iron-blocked I-6 and V-8 engines to aluminum. Because BMW wanted to enjoy the full weight-saving benefits of aluminum-block construction, it spurned the commonly accepted - but rather lowbrow, by BMW standards - practice of fitting cast-iron cylinder liners in the aluminum blocks to enhance durability.
Instead, BMW engineers opted for Nikasil, a fancy process in which a high-silicon-content cylinder-bore "insert" is placed in the block casting mold; when the aluminum is injected into the mold, the insert melts, but leaves a high-silicon surface right where you want it: on the cylinder bores.
BMW hadn't factored-in high-sulfur U.S. gasoline, though. The Nikasil coating didn't hold up to the effects of heavily sulfured gasoline - and quite a few BMW production engines gave their lives in the prove-out. For the I-6s in the 3- and 5-Series, the Bavarians briefly switched back to iron. This year, aluminum returns - but with the more pedestrian cast-iron liners.
There are alternatives to Nikasil that are more sulfur-resistant, including Alusil and Lokasil (both aluminum/silicon processes); Porsche AG uses Lokasil for its all-aluminum engines. But BMW 3-Series director and product line manager Wolfgang Zeibart admits all these processes are expensive - thus the move to iron liners for the new, '99 3-Series aluminum 6-cyl. engines.
The liner/surface-coating camps each make good points. Makers of higher-priced, premium vehicles tend to prefer the higher-tech, cylinder-coating approach. Yet for smaller engines, using iron liners often negates a goodly portion of the weight saved in the switch to an all-aluminum block. This aspect was underscored when General Motors Corp. converted the block of the old LT1/LT4 V-8 to aluminum in creating the new LS1 V-8. Engineers kept iron cylinder liners.
John Juriga, the lead GM Powertrain engineer for the LS1, summed it up in an interview in '97: "We've seen some problems others have had with Nikasil and other coatings," he said. "The cast-in liners are a good, reliable method; the weight penalty really isn't that great """"