Post by
Exar-Kun »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/exar-kun-u1725.html
Sun Nov 28, 2004 4:02 pm
Holly misinformation and crappy speculation by the uninformed batman!
I prescribe reading or all of you! Stat!
Seriously guys. I can't even being to correct the miss-information going on here. It's like some of you have read just enough to get yourselves in trouble by bickering.
Yes, it sounds like I'm picking a fight with all of you, I'm not. I'm being honest. This forum has degenerated since my own, Dori^2, C-kwik and SmithSR's life problems/duties interfering with our jobs of keeping this kind of crap to a minimum.
There have been some truths in here, even good advice-but it's just been too conjecture and baseless assumptions being thrown out for me to sit by and watch this happen over and over...
So I'll make my statements, and its obvious looking over this debate that most people partaking in it shouldn’t be, and HAVEN'T read the FAQ.
Here we go anyways!
1. Wider is not always better. Get this out of your head. Race teams with heavy cars run wide, under inflated(relative to any tire YOU or 99% of the driving population will touch) tires, because when you have a wide tire, and under inflate it, you get a large, nearly square contact patch that is quite large. Increasing your traction.1a. this is not to say this same theory applies to street cars. Street tires have a diminishing rate of return with pressure. you can increase overall contact patch by reducing pressure, but you also create other problems including sidewall deformation under load, high speed load and stability and steering response....race tires are made with that in mind...you're tires aren't1b. Just because you see a wide wheel on a car doesn't mean it's a correct setup. I've seen more M3's and other track ready cars run the narrower tires with sticker compounds than vice versa. Unless you have both the tools, knowledge, and money to utilize tire, wheel and suspension measurements and setups....you probably shouldn't be beyond certain know results. This means that if you don't understand scrub radius, kingpin inclination, alignment measurements, void ratio and a host of other things, you shouldn't even begin to debate about why running a wide wheel may or may not be beneficial.1c. Wide wheels work on heavy cars because the additional poundage created the aforementioned squarer contact patch. There are only a few ways to increase traction/handling realistically:-Make the suspension keep the tire in better contact with the road under all conditions (IE flat with the road)..This usually isn't possible, but it is possible to optimize your suspension for your own purposes, increasing lateral grip by decreasing contact patch deformation by the suspension.-Get a larger contact patch. Contrary to popular belief (again! covered in the FAQ!) wide wheels don't "make more contact patch", all they do is widen it. This may or may not help your handling (and can hinder it substantially) , so choose carefully. You COULD get some tires that are made to run a lower air pressure, increasing contact patch area. But this is expensive (race tires cost money folks)-Get a larger contact area of the tread. This means getting a tire with larger tread blocks, or a lower void ratio. Putting more friction compound in contact with the road for the given contact patch. This is why tires like the BFgoodrich G-force KD and Falken Azenis RS do so well...they have low void ratios. There’s no 'magic compound', just a sticky compound and lots of it. Unfortunately this also means less area for water and noise to move, so these tires are noisy and have worse wet weather traction.-Get a sticker tire. The friction coefficient of a tire for a given heat range is what really makes a high performance tire what it is, some of them have more expensive, stickier, more heat stable compounds. These aren’t cheap. If you don't want to ante up for a good sticky tire, I don't want to hear about how you run a 'wide wheel for better handling' when running a stickier tire would have been a much better investment. Anyways, the stickier the compound, the quicker it wears, and sometimes depending on how 'good' the compound is ($$$$ related), it may result in heat tolerance ranges of stickiness and greasiness (silica does this, FYI)
Onto part 2:
2a. If you don't understand your cars suspension, DON'T mess with it. Leave it to people who DO. Read up, read books, READ THE FAQ, chat with racers at SOLO events, shops, etc if they let you. You’ll learn tons, and don't make stupid statements, learn to respectfully ask questions about things you don't know. 2b. Quit spreading misinformation. This is my biggest pet peeve, and I will be cracking down on it. If you don’t KNOW, Don’t say anything! FIND OUT! What the hell ever happened to just going 'you know, I don't know the answer to that" and trying to FIND IT? Lately it's all about what "you've heard" or "I read somewhere" screw that. Look it up and come back, or wait for someone who does know to answer the question. Wrong information (even if meant to be helpful) just leads to more confusion and the spread of miss-information as fact....baka.
ON performance:
THE TIRES GRIP ON THE ROAD IS YOUR PERFORMANCE LIMIT. PERIOD. CORNERING ACCELRATION, BRAKING, WHATEVER. GET IT THROUGH YOUR HEADS.
This means, if you can increase your suspensions ability to keep the tire in proper alignment to the road, you'll perform better, if you have a sticker (heat tolerant) tire, you'll perform better, a lower void ratio tire will perform better because more compounds is on the road...
See where this goes? It's really that simple. Lower your car excessively, limiting load transfer/body roll, and other things all help TO A POINT, and then it hurts...ever head of "ideal frame height", and how that affects your suspensions reactions to the road?
Also, if you can lock your brakes, you need better tires. Once you experience heat fade from hard stopping with a sticky tire, then come crying to me about brakes being inadequate. Larger brakes won't stop you faster unless heat is what’s causing your brakes to not function properly.
I'm sick of typing, and this topic is closed. From now on, I see this kind of miss-information thrown around masquerading as a debate, I'm deleting it.
No go read up.
If you were offended-GOOD! Go read! Teach ME something!If you were offended, but not enough to look anything up, or learn something- GO TO ANOTHER BOARD YOU FREAKING LEECH.
-Chet
Pissed, frustrated, and tired of this crap.ASlo, dida nyone notice that that last debate didnt apply to this topic AT ALL! stay on topic people.