I had an X for 3 winters now 4th coming. I don't really liked the idea to switch tires 2 times a year. Few reasons why. Nobody can argue the snow tires are the best in snow. However they have a bad side. Even in cold weather they not as good as a good all season tire when the road is dry or only wet. For me that is the deal braking to get snow tires. You have to look at the number of days it snowing vs. number of days not.
AWD will help you at accelerating and turning in wet and snow. I hit big snow piles when I ended up shaving the snow and the X did not stop for a bit. Even when I stopped it in big snow and started it did get out without any effort. However at braking AWD will do nothing more than RWD. But AWD with summer tires in snow almost as bad as rwd with summer tires.
There is no perfect solution since winter tires will suffer(braking) at dry/wet road in winter and gives you really good braking in snow.All season will suffer at braking in snow but gives you better braking and cornering at wet and dry cold days.
Hope this helps
Here is an article winter tires vs all season tires on a RWD G35. It shows few snowtires on the G35 and all season tires in wet/dry and snow in cold. It shows the braking and skidpad #'s. Intersting #'s.
http://www.caranddriver.com/fe...tests