r3dbullz90 wrote:Here is what a friend of mine whos big into cars told me to get. let me know what you think.
I know you said to stay away from drilled but i can get a drilled and slotted rotor(in black... matches my wheels lol) with a lifetime cracking and warping warranty from brakeperformance.com for 131 for the front and 104 for the rear. and then to get duralast gold brake pads(lifetime warranty) all around which are about 70 bucks for all 4. another friend of mine told me i should get a cheap rotor and get really good brake pads like hawk hp's or ebc green stuff... idk what to do... ive gotten different stuff from people i trust around here...
What do you think?
You asked me what I think, so here goes:
Your friend is dumb... and you can tell him I said so.
Reason #1:
Drilled rotors are a waste of money and have universally been proven to do diddly-squat for a street car. I don't care how "hardcore" you think you drive, you will never, ever, ever see enough benefit from a drilled rotor (which WILL crack prematurely) to make it worth the money (or the additional maintenance).
Reason #2:
"Black rotors"? You realize metal is silver and shiny, right? Any company selling "black" rotors is a joke. It would have to be a coating, and that coating will be worn off the minute your pads make contact with the braking surface. If you want to paint the rotor hat, great. But no one sees it anyway.
Reason #3:
There's no "lifetime warranty against warping and cracking." Someone can't read.

There's a 2-year warranty against W & C, and a lifetime warranty against "defects" (which is silly). You also only get ONE warranty return, after that you're S.O.L. You pay the return shipping (which won't be cheap - rotors are heavy). Read the fine print. By the way, that coating isn't covered, and you can't use any kind of cleaner on it, or it will remove the coating... Also silly.
Reason #4:
"duralast gold brake pads"? If you want AutoZone stuff, you'll get AutoZone performance. Better slow down though, because your brakes will be sub-standard.
Your OTHER friend who recommended a regular rotor and good pads, is a little smarter - If you'll see my post, that was what I recommended. However, if EBC or Hawk were "all that," I would have recommended them. In my personal experience, Hawks are overrated. For the same $, I prefer the Ferodo DS2500 (which is used on the Nismo 370Z, and I run on ALL my higher-hp vehicles).
You're probably overthinking it. But, it's good to get all the knowledge you can.
