tollboothwilley wrote:
Perry...
I understand what you are saying here but the grounding kit made a HUGE difference. It is one of the best things that you can do for the 5AT. I can't recommend the grounding kit highly enough.
You may have had a defective ground or as I suspect in some cases and I don't mean yours misinterpret an improvement.
If you restored the car to normal operation by fixing a ground than my point is that you could have fixed the factory ground and not expose the car to possible other problems due to poor grounding techniques being used by the far majority of kits. You could augment the factory grounds by basically guarantee their function for example by doing following proper grounding techniques.
Now to the second point. If you introduce a problem in the ground that makes the car act more like you may want it to then that is what I mean to misinterpreting an improvement. As only an example the transmission shifts 'sharper'. Well maybe it is not designed to shift in this manner and an induced signal now makes it shift a little bit more on the harsh side. Not necessarily a good thing, but seems like a benefit to many.
I suspect that what one sees is one or the other or both. They have indeed fixed what was broken or they have induced an actual change from the norm which they interpret as beneficial.
What I find and I am going to use the term I was avoiding is that many of these claims by various manufactures are 'snake oil'. That is you are not actually changing the ground of a balance sensor for example since it has no ground that can be change. Not all sensor on the Nissan are balanced.
The same pertains to the sound system. Most of the audio parts of the sound system interconnects on at least the newer ones are balanced.
Basically on a balanced system the way it functions is that you have a positive and negative set of leads, the only ground may be a shield. The leads are often twisted, sometimes not. The idea is that if a noise is introduced in one the same noise is also introduced in the other. On the other end a differential amplifier which really doesn't amplify in the normal sense (1 volt in 1 volt out for example) amplifies the difference in signal. Since the noise is equal in both the negative and positive it is esssentially eliminated.
A grounding system would have little affect on this type of system since neither side is grounded and negative effects added by it will most likely simply disappear at the differential amplifier input.
If you want a ground system here are some things to look for. One is that for signal purposes the smallest diameter wire that can carry the load is beneficial. Do not stack grounds at all costs. Use a ring connector, a grounding block, some method of not allowing one conductor to introduce resistance into the group of other conductors. Keep conductors short as they have resistance per foot characteristics. Keep in mind that the goal is usually to keep all components at the same potential, different lengths of cables almost guarantees the chance for circular currents, the same problem with stacked connectors. All conductors within a system should be close to the same length.
If you have cable ends (which you don't necessarily have to have (grounding block for example) then you don't want normal crimped on ends, look for ones where a sufficient pressure method was used to cause a cold welded connection to be made. In utilities an explosive method is actually used for some very high current situations on high voltage lines. For our purpose the same concept applies the idea is to cold weld the connection. Note I didn't state solder which is often what is used by many as a cold welding technique, it is a pressure method of fusing the connector to the conductor.
If you go to the net and do a little research you will find some kits that do try to employ some of these features (for example a ring where the ground is attached and the rest of the conductors are attached to it). Some kits used the idea of a single conductor through the system. Basically a series of single grounding blocks are bolted into place on the chassis and a single conductor flows through them. The idea here I think is to jumper any bad factory ground connections that are body (chassis) based.
Still some kits simply replaced the factory grounds and may augment that with jumping across bolted sections such as outer fender to inner fender, firewall to fender, fender to radiator mount, radiator mount to headlights, and so on, simply jumping sections with very short conductors. I mention this since this is actually something I have seen and to a limited extent done with success after body repairs played games with something like headlight grounds. In an industrial grounding scheme this is often done between bolted together sections, especially control systems.
Perry