Post by
ken in az »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/ken-in-az-u105959.html
Fri May 01, 2009 1:27 pm
Q45Tech I hear you. Today's ecu's - especially nissan's, are so robust it is a little overkill in my mind. Uprev can upload 5 different tunes into one ecu and you can switch them on the fly using your cruise control button! that's trick in my book! Plus, the 06 and up 45's have factory wideband O2 sensors as the primary - no need for an aftermarket wideband sensor now.
With a tune on a stock unmodified 45 I would expect at most 3% gain in peak, but the midrange is where you get your fun to drive factor and that's where the tune is best. For a modified car, and I mean "modified" with the ability to not only tune the ignition and timing, but also the cam advance and the power valve. Maybe even a different intake manifold since the stock one sux. Add in a set of LT headers and remove the cats or add in larger "high flow" cats that are designed to take the abuse and I could see an honest to goodness 10-15% gain across the board.
I only say this because it has been done time and time again on the nissan Titans.
And Q45Tech definitely brings up a good point about engine longevity and what purpose are you using the vehicle for. 1/4 mi, endurance, road race, top speed. I would be most here would have the car be a daily driver with an occasional 1/4mi pass here and there. I would hope that if anyone that would be getting into the other forms of racing understand the ramifications of racing and the damage you can do to them. Even our beloved site with there G37s project experienced higher oil temps while roadracing their brand new car - and get this - the ECU actually limited RPM due to excessively high oil temperatures. That's High Tech and saved the bunch a high repair bill if you ask me.
As I understand the older VH45 engine was built better from the factory to handle more extremes, it had lower ringlands on the pistons, bigger valves, girdled main, all sorts of stuff. Hell even the old VG30e would handle tons of boost on a stock engine. I made 450rwhp on a junk yard v6 that lived a very long life. But we have to work with what we have. I believe the VK56DE has the same upper piston ring dimension as the 45 and the last I heard it lasted through 450ish rwhp, but died when it was being tuned for high boost - 9lbs at 519rwhp.
I'd "assume" that we'd be safe as long as the A/F ratio was kept in check as you'd need a very lean mixture on an NA application to cause high enough pressures in the cylinder to cause those issues.
whew - long post, gotta run but for those that think an ECU tune is going to yield 30-40hp think again. We are looking at an honest 7-12rwhp peak and about the same on TQ. mid range and full throttle restrictions removed will just simply make the car more fun to drive, which was what I posted originally.
Have a great weekend everyone, I know I will. Drift and Drags tonight at firebird. Email me if you want to meet up.