Post by
kerrton »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/kerrton-u88348.html
Mon Nov 22, 2010 12:59 pm
Well I've got a Rogue, I have 2 young kids (both in car seats) and an 80 lb dog. The hatch is great for the dog, and we routinely put two 80 lb dogs in the cargo area no problem when I bring a buddy along. The rear seat has tons of leg room which equals that or the Murano I believe, but you have less width. I did recently add a roof top cargo box to add more cargo storage on those longer trips, so I get really great utility and amazing gas mileage especially around town.
However, if you're going to compare the Rogue to the Murano of course the Murano wins in most categories except fuel efficiency and cost - it just so happens that efficiency and price were high on my list so I bought a Rogue but your priority list will likely be a little different. The Murano is significantly more money but you get a bigger vehicle, however if you compare a base model Murano to a loaded Rogue the cost gap is almost Nil. Also if the Rogue will meet your needs you could probably get a brand new one, loaded with AWD, leather etc. for roughly the same price as a gently used Murano, then no worries about how the previous owner treated the car and you have full warranty.
I'm not trying to sell you on one or the other, it just depends on personal preference, individual needs, and the deals that are available when you go to purchase. The Murano cargo area is quite a bit larger and it sounds like you would appreciate the extra room, but I've always felt that the Murano is priced a little too high when new. If you can snag a good deal on a used one that is a big consideration. I love my Rogue but I'm also a big fan of Hyundai, and if looking at the Murano I have to recommend checking out the Santa Fe just for comparision (we have 2 in our family and they are amazing) No offense to any Murano owners, the Murano is a great vehicle but if you check out the Santa Fe I'd bet money that you'll be sold on it and be amazed at what you get for the price including amazing build quality and a 5yr/8yr warranty which is unbeatable. Sorry guys I know this is a Nissan forum and I too love Nissan but on this forum I think the primary goal is to look out for fellow members or potential members and regardless of what vehicle you're looking at it's always good advice to compare and cross-shop other brands a little bit - if nothing else it'll prove that your Nissan is exactly what you need! Good luck man!