nametakennow wrote:The Spec V has a different target market than the "base" SE-R.
The Spec V is more geared towards the vast majority of the "tuning" crowd, it gets more visual cues and a supposed hp boost. The transmission is a true difference, but that's beside the point. Some people who would normally buy Civic Si's are buying Spec Vs, Nissan wins.
If I were buying a daily and weren't the nut that I am, I'd get a Spec V for the simple fact that it's a little sportier stock, and stock is nice when you want to keep your warranty.
However, if I were doing a project, why bother spending more for what you're going to remove? A complete Spec V conversion is pointless. If my car was purely a project, the side skirts and larger front bumper would HAVE to go, as would the wing (though my wing is going bye-bye one day anyway, if I can find a wingless blackout trunk for sale, ever).
Yes, there is a pretty big SR/QR rivalry. I don't buy into it much, I think they're overall different motors, both with potential. I prefer the SR for the beefier internals and ease of boost, it comes with a boss on the block for oil drain, all you have to do is drill and tap it, just like Nissan does at the factory, not to mention the fact that there are many different turbo manifolds that bolt right on, so it's a lot cheaper (my turbo, mani, intake pipe, and BOV cost me $550 shipped, overall my turbo project is going to run me ~$2k). Not to mention the fact that I could take over 300whp before needing internal work.
The QR, of course, has mind-blowing torque in the low rpms. I like a fat midrange because I prefer backroads cruising to all out stoplight runs, the SR gives me that. The QR would be a LOT of fun to do a heavy all motor build on, and I will admit, it has a slightly meaner sound.
...
Okay, so the QR makes me want to crap my pants, it just sounds EVIL. I love my SRs growl and all, but that extra half liter is noticeable.
I think you're incorrect about the crowd thing with the differences between the Spec and the base SE-R. So we will just have to agree to disagee. Paying THAT much extra for things you're just going to throw away is silly. As I said, you'er going to throw away everything except the transmission and the interior.
But I will agree with you that the SR vs QR thing is completely stupid. As you said, they're different motors. The SR has what? Like 15 years of development and is in HOW many platforms? The QR originally was in like 4 platforms and has only been out since like 2002.
270whp is about all you can do safely on the internals on the QR, and that will cost you about $4k for the kit to do so. On the plus side, there are starting to be mroe options for us QR powered guys. Valve trains, rods, pistons, cams, headers (yes, plural since there is more than one manufacturer....heehheeh), exhausts, suspension parts.
Me, I'm not so big on the cosmetic. I like my side skirts. They're probably staying. I love the front-end. It just needs a lip. The back? I'm not so keen on the back, but I haven't seen a rear kit that rings my bell. Even when I get my car done with all of the stuff I wanna do, it's still probably going to look mostly stock, because I, for the most part, like the looks. Hell, I even like the blue color my car is. I am just goign to get it shot with better paint and a deeper looking finish.