Larz wrote:I'm with you, mate. One of the things I do early-on after buying a car is switch to Mobil-1 5w30. I have never used any other brand. This is the first time trying the 5w20 and I think you have a good point regarding the heat down here and lack of cold starting temps. I'm gonna go back to the 5w30 at the next change. I reckon that Mobil coats and protects the engine well enough that 5w30 should be fine for any mileage. As for the price, I get the 5-quart jugs at Walmart for about $25. No matter how many pennies you have, nothing wrong with pinching them!
I'm pretty sure the first number is the cold rating (relevant to starting / environment) and the second number is the operating temp rating. Given that, switching between the use of 5w20 and 5w30 would not affect starting even if there were cold starting temps. I'm also pretty sure the manual says 5w30 even for high temp environments, so I'm not sure why you'd go to 10w30 unless you were trying to fight oil consumption during warmup (and I have no idea if that would be effective or not). OTOH, if talking about the hot environment in regards to the second number, I'm pretty sure the second number is rated at boiling temp, which you don't want your engine to raech, so when operating your engine at full temp, the environmental temperature should no longer be relevant to the oil, and as such, I can't imagine any reason you would want to run, for instance, 5w40, even in Florida (again, short of thinking it might reduce consumption, this time at operating temperature).
ETA: I guess I should clarify that I understand the typical reasons for deviating on the second number, involving fuel mileage and engine protection (running 5w20 instead of 5w30 for better efficiencey at the cost of engine protection vs running 5w40 instead of 5w30 for better engine protection at the cost of reducet fuel efficiency). The post I am editing was just about my not understanding why Antz and Larz were discussing environment in regards to the oil he was running (with plenty of segues as is typical when I type).