Post by
jackdar »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/jackdar-u71540.html
Mon Jul 23, 2007 4:33 pm
The current cars in my household are a black/black 2003 G35 Coupe 6MT with premium and aero package, and a white/black 2006 BMW X3 6 speed with premium and sport packages.
In April, I drove to New York to see the premier of the 2008 G37, and at the end of May placed my order for a black/black 6MT with premium, nav, and spoiler.
Although I think the first generation of the Coupe is destined to be a classic, having seen the new body style, I am very much looking forward to driving this new beauty. I have only given minor consideration to the BMW 335 coupe. That engine with 300 foot pounds of torque being available from 1400 to 5200 rpm has got to be a thrill to experience. By the same token, the car I drove prior to my coupe was a Subaru WRX which is also turbo charged, at the same time my wife's car was a 2003 Saab 9-3 also with a turbo. Both of these cars lugged around corners in 2nd gear. Now apparently, BMW has remedied this issue, but I remain skeptical. The 335 coupe is a good looking car, but the G37 has much better lines and a style that will be more appealing for many years to come (IMHO).
Although we would probably buy the X3 again - primarily because it was the best performing mini-ute that had a 6 speed - it has some issues that you would not expect in a $44K vehicle. My major gripes include the interiorm, such as: the dash in general ( unimaginative ), the speedometer and tach ( both are too small and have very limited markings ), the stereo ( to turn it off, you have to repeatedly press the low volume button until it turns off ), the quality of the plastics is of a very low quality ( dull and hard). I don't understand how BMW gets a "pass" on this issue. The quality of the leather on the high touch areas (steering wheel, shift knob, and e-brake handle) after 16 months - shows signs of wear that my G35 doesn't show after 4 years. Finally, on anything but smooth roads, the ride is down-right harsh and punishing. I generally prefer a firm ride, but this is an area where BMW received a lot of complaints and fixed it in the 07 X3.
My G35 Coupe on the other hand feels like a part of me when I drive it. You wear this car more than drive it. When I read the reviews of the new car, the one thing that concerns me is...has Infiniti made it too much of a touring car and "tamed" its rawness. I used to complain about the vibration in the shifter, until I realized the alternative. The shifter in the X3 is totally motionless....which made me realize that those vibrations were "the pulse" of the engine. I have driven BMW coupes and would get out thinking Yes it is a nice car that handles very well but the experience seemed too refined...as if they have gone for too much luxury...at the expense of that personal connection. The one complaint that is legitimate about the G35's VQ is the unpleasant harshness that you hear when the revs reach 5000 rpm....this is the one area of improvement that I would welcome more than any other.
I am 56 years old and have owned many great driving cars, this will be the only time I have purchased the same car twice in a row. I love my G35 Coupe and look forward to a long and rewarding relationship with the G37.
One of the best things about the G37 though is that it will force the next round of competition by which we will all benefit from higher quality and better performance at a greater value.