I second this opinion. The stock internals are not meant for boost. Low HP not withstanding, if you're going through all that trouble I'd build a motor that will last for many boosted miles to come. Also, do it right the first time. If money is tight, take your time collecting parts. Plus, one of our sponsors has a solid rebuild for under $2,000 - I'd check that out.Kaleo55 wrote:I think if you have the luxury of building a second motor and not the one you're using, then don't cut corners. Don't buy cheap parts just to get it done, save a little longer and get the best you can afford. If you're going through the trouble of tearing down a old motor, it makes more sense to rebuild with fortified internals, especially if you are planning to boost. There are a lot of options available to you (KA24DE) so, consider them well.
I want to buy a spare motor and rebuid it because:Chezedik wrote:Uhm, I guess no one is going to say it... Why rebuild for only 230hp, all of the existing kits that I am aware of will make that in stock form. All you need to do is install a Walbro. And an FMU can be a perfectly safe option if it is kept well inside of it's operating range. Like anything else, when you exceed the range is when things start to break. The IAP kit made 238whp with an FMU at 8psi, or so they claim. N-sport makes 232whp with an FMU at 8psi. You figure it out.
If you could make me a list, that would be great. My budget did not include only parts. I had the rebuild ($800) in there and spare motor cost ($300).Florida240sx wrote:3k budget???? That is easy to get 240rwhp. Get Revhard mani,T3 turbo of your choice, Safc II, 370cc injectors or 440cc, z32mafs, walboro fuel pump, then whatever you want for fmic bov.... Don't forget to factor in $400 for a upgraded clutch I can build you a list if you like. Did one the other night came out to $2300.
I didn't know that the ignition retard was necessary with the SAFCII. After an endless amount of time searching, I've heard nothing but bad things about the FMU and stock injectors/ECU. Thanks for setting that straight. I plan to run a maximum of 10 psi if that tells you anything. With Florida's help, I will post a new/updated list of parts.WDRacing wrote:For the record, a high flow fuel pump and a FMU will work great. Anyone who says different has no idea what they are talking about. Tuning the SAFCII isn't for everyone. If you're going for larger injectors and a SAFCII then you'll also need ignition retard on boost. So then you have the get the MSD BTM...for all of that you could get a MSII standalone.
For low boost, the FMU WILL work just fine. Just make sure the fuel pump can keep up with the pressure increase.
WD
The reason why I am not just piecing a kit together is that, in my experience, and according to Murphy's Law, " if something can go wrong, it will." I don't want to rush through this. Besides, I have to do everything by myself; I have no one to help me. I don't think my motor is in prime condition to be boosted. I would be able to sleep at night knowing that nothing has been overlooked.prang11 wrote:I am currently sourcing parts to almost do the same setup as you except I am going to run a T25. Seems to be the poor mans turbo setup and an easy way to reach 180-190 hp.
I do agree with kaleo, if you are building a motor outside your car you might as well take the time to do it right. It sounds like you are in the same boat as me wanting to turbo the car with minimal down time. Well why not put together a kit and take a weekend to bolt it all up? Thats my plan.
Good luck with the build.
I know a rebuild is not going to be easy, that's why I consider this a long-term project; I don't plan to have this done in a month. I understand that people telling me what to do is not what i should be doing, but I am seeking adivce as to what others have done. I am seeking only a very basic setup for now, and what I have been told by Florida is what I figured a while back; I only wanted a list of prices. I've also checked out ka-t.org as well and I did learn a good deal.babowc wrote:hm..rebuilding a motor is no easy task.im going for it as well, and i dont expect it to be a cake on a platter.
btw, you need to do your own research and figure it out..people telling you what to do, and what to buy isnt going to help achieve what you want in the end.
find out for yourself what your power goals are, also read up on here and forums dedicated to turbocharging the KA.
anyhow, you have alot more planning to do..i've been planning for nearly 1.5years now, and im finally getting things rolling. or ?
I know I could get away with replacing the oil and water pump and some other components, but I want to rebuild because I've never done it, and I like knowing how things work. I never said I was going to use expensive parts.nissanfanatic wrote:Why do you guys spend all that money rebuilding an engine and then do SAFC and 370s..?? Maybe your money is going to the wrong stuff..?? If you are spending over 1000 on rebuilding an engine, you should at least spend that on an ECU tune and good injectors(deatschwerks)..
You don't need to build an engine for 230whp. You shouldn't rebuild unless you are going for over 350whp. If you pop it under that power level, you ****ed up, not the engine..
To the OP, I'd just buy a known good engine and keep it as a backup if you must..
One of the main reasons whay I want to swap is that my motor sounds/performs pretty badly. It's very noisy, doesn't make much power. When I checked the ECU for codes, the Camshaft Position Sensor came up, but according to the FSM several things could be wrong. That is not the only thing that's wrong, just one of the main things that I know for CERTAIN. I want to check oil pressure and compression, which I don't think will be very good..Chezedik wrote:You really do not need to even replace that. Seriously, the IAP kit is good for that power level, and many people have had a ton of success with them. Also, the KA holds on to compression forever, so unless you know of a problem you are not telling us, then you are fine. Remember, it's just as easy to blow up a new motor, as an old when, if you have a bad tune.
For the oil pump, by purchasing a lower mileage engine, it will be much easier to replace out of the car. I want it to be a learning experience. I really don't plan to make much power, I just want to do it myself. If I had the money, I would probably purchase your motor, but I don't. That budget that I set up is over the span of probably a year or two, not a few months. I thought I could get this done by the summer but I now don't see this happening.Chezedik wrote:But rebuilding the engine won't change the fact that you need a distributor (but buying my motor may, with the lifetime warrantee'd (sp?) dizzy that I have ). Also, the KA is just kind of a noisy engine, check your valve lash, and that will help it. I also have a ton of lifter shims if you need them for adjusting lash. The oil pump on the KA is pretty tough, so unless someone just totally abused this engine, you may not be giving it all the credit it deserves.
I think I may have found my savior. There is a guy selling a motor and transmission with 67K original miles. With this, I won't have to replace anything really, if it is in good condition. I will have to put the rebuild on hold for awhile since I KNOW it will cost a good deal of money. I am kind of leaning more towards the SAFC and SR 370's now because it seems like a safer option.Chezedik wrote:Fair enough, spec out the parts, and you will save a ton. Many parts do not need replacement during a rebuild, just look in the manual it will walk you through it. The dizzy is expensive, I may suggest a used unit, but that is your business. I paid over 200 bux.