maxnix wrote:Actually, I think there is a net power loss as now the engine is powering a larger alternator continuously.
"Continuously" is probably an overstatement. The alternator only produces drag when it is actually generating current...and the fan only draws current when it is actually running. Typically, the thermostat is set to turn on the fan only when supplemental cooling is needed. The rest of time, the fan's contribution to alternator drag is nil.
Meanwhile, a belt-driven fan is always producing some drag, because the viscous clutch never completely disconnects the fan from the pulley - The fan "freewheels" at some speed that is lower than engine speed, drawing some engine power in the process.
My biggest problem with electric fans is that they rarely are capable of moving as much air as a properly-functioning belt-driven fan. There are times when you actually need 5 horsepower worth of air movement - and the laws of physics say that a half-horsepower electric fan motor just isn't capable of accomplishing the same thing.