Honestly I'm not sure yet as I'm only running a Stage 1 tune with the catback. I will upgrade to the Stage 2 once I get the HFC's installed (and will take it to a shop for a more appropriate custom tune). More me being cautious than anything else. Stillen states 14.5hp for headers, Cobb states 11% HP increase with stage 2 tune. It took me 1/2 an hour to "install" the Cobb (that includes backing up the default flash and flashing with phase 1) whereas the header install would have been a day of misery
. Cost wise they are both close (dependent on headers that are purchased).
I'm not a butt-dyno kinda guy so until I actually get to the track I won't know real improvements.