maxnix wrote:Traditionally, muscle cars have been midsize bodies with big cast iron OHV engines, 3 speed autos or 4 speed manuals, under sized brakes with disc front, drum rear, solid cast iron axles, and pretty bad suspensions and tires.
Mustangs, Camaros, Javalins and Barracudas were pony cars. Challengers and Cougars were stretched versions of their corporate brethren.
Exactly. A muscle car is just a basic family car stripped of the unnecessary with a huge engine. Very different from smaller, more agile purpose-built pony cars.
I agree that they are not in the same "class" per-se, but that doesn't mean they shouldn't be cross-compared. Especially the new Camaro, which is a fairly strong departure from ponycar tradition. A V6 worth having, advanced suspension, nice interior...it's really a great competitor for the Z. The Mustang is an entirely different story with it's crude 30-year-old gutless V6 and it's snow-plow understeer. But the Camaro, at least, is worth holding up next to the Z.
Still, if you want a Z, you want a Z. And this is definitely one of the best Z-cars in the model's history.