Innovazn wrote:...Strongly advised to test drive both engines and variants before you make the purchase!
This is EXCELLENT advice, but...
I discovered the 3.5 was hard to find in the Coupe and one with the 6sp manual transmission version was a unicorn... Impossible to test drive.
The closest I came was driving a co-worker's 2008 3.5 6sp sedan. Since the 6sp is now only offered in the 6sp coupe, a true comparison may prove VERY difficult.
I ultimately bought a 3.5 6mt that the local dealership had to go waaaay out of area to find and LOVE it! I guess it was a bit of a leap of faith to buy without driving but the dealership shipped the car in on nothing other than my curiosity- no deposit, no promises. They called me, I drove it as was SOLD.
I can't speak about any other variants of the coupe since I never drove anything other than mine and have never driven anything with the CVT. I still suggest driving what you can before diving in though; I'm just a bit older and knew what I wanted.
If you have never driven a manual transmission car, it is not difficult to learn but I would search out one (maybe even a rental) to get a basic feel before diving into a purchase. The Altima drivetrains are pretty darn tough, shift well and have a light clutch compared to most cars out there. In traffic, it is easy to drive and doesn't result in fatigue. For actual "performance" most manual transmission drivers will get their butts kicked in a drag-race in a comparable auto car- you just can't miss a shift in an auto! With that said, the driving feel and experience in a manual is preferred my most enthusiasts but that is a personal preference (mine being obvious, I bought a 6sp).
If the transmission is not a decider (you are looking at only the CVT automatic) then comparing a 2.5 to a 3.5 will be easier based on availability of the cars. Given the 2 side-by-side, the choice for
me would be even easier- 3.5 any day and twice on Sunday! The "smiles-per-gallon" are well worth it!
Hope that helps a little...
/r
Allen