So they smelled me coming I'm having the same problem, (fuel at roughly the same amount of disproportion) - 100 miles = half tank crap. You evidently know more about cars than I do, but I fell for my car like a fat guy in a strip club would for a dancer, and she's getting all my money. Anyway, my diagnosis, from trial and error, leads me to think you may want to investigate around the catalytic converter. Here are the list of events. Since September 2006.
1. Smelled Gas and Black smoke -with engine lag- I replaced the exhaust manifolds(both sides) - bought a whole spare engine $750 plus labor because I knew I'd be dedicated to the task
2. Smelled Gas Again - took the car to the mechanic where the mechanic was thoroughly sprayed - I like to say my car pee'd on him. Hose stolen from the old engine replaced on the one in my car. $250
3. 2 days later - Car dies in the snow (while driving) Mechanic sugguests, a bigger battery, because after all haven't you seen all the lights when you open the door.. biggest battery Autozone offers bought and 2 days later car dies again. $450 later alternator replaced by Midas mechanic - cash payment.
4. Growling Sound - hole in exhaust pipe ( passenger side) - appears when people speak about j30 exhaust, they exclude the side - pisses me off 80$ under the table to the same Midas mechanic. Putting his kids through school
5. Fuel problem remains (reduced black smoke however) no more gas smell either - throughout this whole process, what's it now? March Madness? I don't even wanna go anywhere,... anymore , My friends tell me to sale, but I'm all in.. now! Me and Mr Midas - cash only guy - talk it out. Tire Rod, Tire alignment, Fuel Filter, Air Filter, Radiator Plug, Spark Plugs I picked out, and exhaust bracket removal - passenger side- (I had the under the car idle, metal clang noise going on) $350.
03/19/07 - plans to have a mechanic test the fuel injectors, because I'm running out of *beep* to fix - and if the car runs this good when broken, lord knows I wanna see what it'll do when fixed.
6. Then I read it.. - yesterday- 03/24/07
http://auto.howstuffworks.com/...r.htm(because I don't know enough about cars in general)
http://www.howstuffworks.com/question482.htm(this shows all of the symptoms of bad gas mileage, hestitation, and my favorite another exhaust problem.)
In the next month, I'll let you know if this fixes my problem.
If not I'm on to the fuel injectors..
If you find out your problem don't be ashamed to write it up here.. I'll be waiting..