YipMan_Style wrote:Thinking about a new Frontier truck. I will be driving it to work and carry people so crew cab. Will not tow anything.
- Are they good trucks?
- Are they hardy as how trucks should be?
- I4 or V6? I know more about the QR25DE engine. Don't know anything about the 4.0 V6. Outside of power, is one more reliable than another?
- When I talk to truck guys, they say to get a Toyota instead. Agree or disagree? Would you choose Tacoma over the Frontier?
- What do you think of the Toyota Tacoma?
TIA
Hey Yip,
Surprised that not many have given you much traction on your quest for a New Pickup.
Several Frontier's, that I've read about, have gone over 300K mile's, with the VQ40DE Engine. They said mainly just regular Maintenance and as I recall, some have done the Timeing Chain Maintenance. I've been told that the Early Timeing Chain Issue's have been addressed. But @ some point the Engine probably will need Timeing Chain Maintenance, hopefully it'll be over 200k or 300k miles.
I got my 1st Nissan Truck New, in '93; KC, AT, 2WD, 4cyl/KA24E. I drove that little Truck for 20yr's/176K miles, and sold it in 2013,, after I got a New '13 SVV6 Frontier AT, 2WD, KC.
The '93 needed a New Gas Tank @ about 100K Mile's/10 year's. It got a small pin hole leak in the bottom. The Water Pump started leaking @ 174K mile's,, and replaced with a new one. Other than that,, just regular maintenance, The Timeing Chain was still doing good, and the Engine was still good and quiet,, when I sold it.
I don't pay too much attention to those that say a Toyota has a Higher Resale Value. The Condition of the Truck matter's way more, especially the longer that one keep's a Truck. I paid 10K $'s for that '93,, and @ 20 year's & 176K mile's, I got 4K $'s for it. According to KBB, it was worth more than a comparatively equiped Toyota.
I drove all of them before hand, ie Silverado, Ford F150, Ram 1500, Tacoma, & Frontier.
The Nissan Frontier just give's More for the Money.
All of the V6 Frontier's Now, are Rated 1/2 Ton Pickup's. The V6 AT's, come standard with a Transmission Oil Cooler and are Rated to pull over 6200 lbs. My SVV6 KC AT 2WD is rated to pull 6500 lbs right out of the Gate( AFter the Break'in Period) of course. A V6 Tacoma doesn't come standard with a Transmission Cooler for the AT Transmission, and only rated to pull 3500 lb's, unless you get the Tow Package Option, which add's $'s. A Frontier has a Steel Bed,, and a Tacoma has a Plastic Bed.
All in All,, for a 2013 I would have needed to spend more for the Tacoma equipped the same as an SVV6 AT 2WD KC Frontier; at least 5K $'s, and the Toyota Salesman,, said it would have been about 9K $'s more for an equally equipped Tacoma.
If you go Frontier get the V6,, cause the I4 only get's 1 mpg more with the AT, than the V6,, and the V6 is only about 850 $'s more. Difference between 3500 lb's & 6500 lb's of Towing power, Way More Passing/Hill Climbing Power, & about 900lbs versus 1400 lb's max hauling.
But you need to Test Drive all of them, to see which one fit's you best. Much over 6' Tall, and the Frontier may just be too small, and you may have to opt for a Silverado.
Back in 2013,, if Money had not been an object,, I most likely would have gotten an Extended Cab Silverado V6. But it was at least 2 to 3K $'s more then, and now even more $'s Difference.
Never Say Never, I've been told. Pickup's were made to Haul People, Cargo, & Tow Trailer's. Barring a Truck getting Totaled in a Wreck, Eventually,, someone is going to be Hauling Cargo,, & Towing a Trailer. So think about that, as far as Resale Value.
Truck Guy's like V6's, V8's, and Regular Length Bed's(at least 6' Long). 4WD is also very popular,, and also help's on Resale,, but Hurt's MPG and cost's more. I needed MPG,, way more, than I needed 4WD.
If you go Frontier be sure to follow the Break-In instruction's, & Owner Maintenance. The Ring's on my V6 didn't really seat good until a little after 2K mile's. So My advice is to give the break-In a little bit longer, like 2K to 2400 mile's, if possible. That's basically what I did.
Before the Ring's Seated,, I was getting about 19.5 MPG, Mixed Driveing. After the Ring's Seated,, I'm getting aroung 21 MPG, Mixed Driveing over the same Route,, Same Station, Same Pump...
Make it an adventure,, and have Fun,, Testing and Driveing all of the Truck's out there.. Alway's Sleep on it at least over night. If it's a Deal You Can't Refuse,, put down a Deposit,, with the Deal in Writeing,, but still Sleep On It Over Night.
As long as no one Rawhide's, Climb's Big Rock's, Goe's Mudding, or Water Higher than the Axle's,, I would be ok with a Silverado, Tacoma, or Frontier Truck. But not the 3.6 Liter Ram, or the Honda Ridgeline(Just not much of a Truck to me). In other Word's don't try to do those Commercial's, ie Pulling Stump's out of the Ground, or Abuseing Your TRuck. Common Sense is all you need to get your Truck to Last a Long Time.
Most of the Full Size Truck's Now,, are way too big. I just wouldn't feel right about driveing some of those Big Pickup's. And I've got a Class A CDL.
Good Luck
PS, Sorry I typed so much. Sometime's my little Finger's have Way Too Much Energy.
