Post by
scaramoche »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/scaramoche-u160166.html
Sun Jun 27, 2010 10:22 am
First im on the fence about what defines a "musician". I am a musician, can read sheet music, play piano(was classicaly trained), play guitar(badly), and know music theory. Now this being said, these qualifications dont make a musician. Many bands i gig'ed in over the years had very talanted musicians that couldnt read a note, and words like "transpose" were greek to them, yet they knew how to make melodies, harmonise etc with the instrument of there choise.
Now where i have an issue is where the computer does all the work.
Example, not more than a few months ago, I was at a club that show cases new tallent. I met this guys who knew of me, and approuched me to talk "shop". I remmember we started talking, then he told me he was a musician. Now all you peeps who are musicians, we like talking shop. As we began to talk it became apparent really f'n quick that he didnt know one instrument from another(i would like to point out that around this time some of his buddies joined the conversation). What he did was basically used samples and loops to string together making what he called "music". Now ive used FL, but my poison of choice is sony acid pro, and im very familiar with how easy it is to beat match etc with these programs, it's so easy infact my wife has started farting around with it.
either way after about 5min of hearing how they were musicians i said "no you are not, your an artist, but not a musician" this pissed them off, but it was the truth. In hindsight it still pisses me off that they tried to convince me that allowing a computer to do all the legwork constitutes being a musician, yet they did not sample sounds, lay midi tracks(rather they hacked from the web and used other peep's material) etc.
Are they creative? yes, are they artists? yes(much the same way a DJ is), but they are not musicians. I would also like to state, i do like looping and sampling materials, sending through vst's, and vsti's, but 60% of the samples stuff i use was composed by me.